LIBRARY  OF  CONGRESS 


ADDITIONAL 
REFERENCES 

RELATING  TO 


RECIPROCITY 


WITH 


CANADA 


COMPILED  r.VDER  THE  DIRECTION  OF 

HERMANN  HENRY  BERNARD  MEYER 

CHIEF  BlBLIOGRAl'HEU 


8061  'u  mc  m 
A  'AI  'asnoBjig 

Jdpuig 
JunoLuomji 


SOUTHERN  BRANCH, 

UNIVERSITY  OF  CALIFORNIA, 

LIBRARY, 

iLOS  ANGELES,  CALIF. 


TABLE  OF  CONTENTS 


Pages 

Prefatory  note 3^ 

Books 5-7 

Articles  in  periodicals 8-20 

Speeches  in  Congress 21-31 

United  States  documents 32-36 

Canadian  and  British  documents 37-39 


Note. — The  text  of  the  latest  Canadian  tariff  act  may  be  found  in  the  following 
publications:  The  customs  tariff,  1H07,  issued  by  the  Canadian  Department  of 
customs,  1907  (HJ6092.A5.1907);  The  commercial  handbook  of  Canada,  1911 
(HF3223.C7);  The  "Shipping  world"  yearbook,  1910  (HE951.S55). 


112H2Z 


— )    '    ' 


Ki  n 


PREFATORY  ISTOTE 


These  additional  references  bring  the  section  on  Reciprocity  with  Can- 
ada in  the  recently  printed  "Select  list  of  references  on  Reciprocity" 
(pp.  51-81)  down  to  date. 

The  following  brief  notes  on  the  literature  of  Canada  are  offered  to 
meet  the  widespread  interest  in  Canadian  affairs  aroused  by  the  Reci- 
procity agreement. 

General  information  on  Canadian  affairs  will  be  found  in  The  Cana- 
dian annual  review  of  public  affairs  (shelf  mark  F1008.C28);  The 
commercial  handbook  of  Canada  (HF3223.C7);  Canada:  an  encyclo- 
pa?dia  of  the  country  (F100S,H79);  for  contempm'ary  hiography 
consult  the  Canadian  Who's  who  (F1005.C23). 

Statistics  are  given  in  the  following  Canadian  government  publica- 
tions. Census  and  statistics  office,  Bulletin  (11A712.A3);  The  Canada 
year  book  (HA744.S81);  Census  and  statistics  monthh^  (HA1.C3); 
Fourth  census  of  Canada,  1901  (HA7-41.1901).  Department  of  agri- 
culture, The  statistical  year-book  of  Canada,  1885-1904  (IIA711.S8). 
Department  of  customs.  Tables  of  the  trade  and  navigation  of  the 
Dominion  of  Canada  (HF129.A2).  Department  of  finance.  Report  of 
the  auditor  general  (HJ13.A3).  Department  of  inland  revenue, 
Report,  returns,  and  statistics  of  the  iiiland  revenues  of  the  Dominion 
of  Canada  (HJ13.A5).  Department  of  laJ)our,  Wholesale  prices  in 
Canada,  1890-1909  (IID6995  A5).  Department  of  trade  and  com- 
merce. Weekly  report  (IIF129.A27  and  current  tile);  Monthly  report 
(HF129.A3  and  current  file);  Annual  report  (1IFI2!>.A42).  Consult 
also  Great  Hritaiii,  Hoard  of  trade,  Statistical  abstract  for  the  several 
Bi-itisli  colonies,  possessions  and  protectorates  (11A1112). 

The  Resources  and  prod  actions  oi  the  country  are  described  in  R.  J. 
Barrett,  Canada's  century  (HC115.B27);  the  three  following  issued 
by  the  I)(!|)artment<)f  agriculture  of  Canada:  Canada;  its  history,  pro- 
ductions and  natural  resources  prepared  by  (i.  .Johnson  (F1008.C2.51); 
The  forest  wealth  of  Canada  (SI)14:.5.A3);  The  food  products  of  Canada 
(S471.C15A3);  M.  L.  Dinvavrin,  Le  Canada  <^conomi(|U(^  au  xx"  sieclc 
(liCll5.D.->);  J.  S.  .Jeans,  Canada's  resources  and  possibilities  (I1C115. 
J4);  .1.  Mavor,  Northwest  of  Canada  (HD9044.C3A4.5). 

On  the  Uistorij  Itesides  the  extensive  work  of  Kingsfoid.  The  history 
of  Canada,  in  1<>  volumes  (FlOii(;,K.5;"))  and  Barkinairs  Wiitings  (F1030. 

3 


4  PEEFATOEY   NOTE 

P2i),  consult  Sir  J.  G.  Bourinot,  The  story  of  Canada  (F1026.B77); 
A.  P.  Cockburn,  Political  annals  of  Canada  (F1026.C66);  J.  S.  Willison, 
Sir  Wilfrid  Laurier  and  the  Liberal  party  (F1033.W73). 

Dcscrij)tion  and  travel  of  recent  date  are  to  be  found  in  the  Duke  of 
Argyll's,  Yesterday  and  to-day  in  Canada  (F1015.A71);  A.  G.  Bradley, 
Canada  in  the  twentieth  century  (F1008.B81);  J.  F.  Fraser,  Canada  as 
it  is  (F1015.F84);  H.  J.  Morgan,  Canadian  life  in  town  &  country 
(F1015.M84);  H.  K.  Whates,  Canada  the  new  nation  (F1015.W55). 

On  the  CoTistltution  and  government  consult  Sir  J.  G.  Bourinot,  How 
Canada  is  governed  (JL28.B6);  and  the  same  author's  Parliamentary 
procedure  and  practice  in  the  Dominion  of  Canada  (JL148.B7.1903); 
Report  on  the  constitution  of  the  Dominion  of  Canada,  prepared  by 
J.  A.  Chapleau  and  issued  by  the  Department  of  Secretary  of  state 
of  Canada  (JL65.1891.A3);  H.  E,  Egerton,  Canadian  constitutional 
development  (JL11.E3);  J.  E,  C.  Munro,  The  constitution  of  Canada 
(JL61.M8). 

Cu'rre7it  Canadian  opinion^  both  French  and  English,  is  reflected  in 
the  following  journals:  Halifax,  Morning  chronicle;  Montreal,  Ca- 
nadian journal  of  commerce  (HF1.C2),  La  Presse,  Star;  Toronto, 
Globe,  Mail  and  empire,  Canadian  manufacturer  (TS1.C22),  Industrial 
Canada,  Monetary  times  (HF1.M66) ;  Winnipeg,  Free  press. 

H.  H.  B.  Meyer 
Chief  Bibliogra'ph&r 

Herbert  Putnam 

Librarian  of  Congress 

Washington,  I).  C,  April  J/,,  1911 


ADDITIONAL  REFERENCES  RELATING  TO 
RECIPROCITY  (CANADA) 


BOOKS 


Ashley,  Percy  Walter  Llewellyn.     Modern  tariflf  history:  Germany — 
United  States — France.     2d  ed. 
London:  J.  Murray,  1910.     x,  U'^  pp.     8°. 

"The  first  edition  of  this  book,  published  in  1904,  was  based 

upon  lectures  delivered  to  the  students  of  the  London  school 

of  economics  and  political  science,  in  the  course  of  that  year." 

"A  brief  bibliography  "  at  end  of  each  part. 

"The  United  States  and  reciprocity — economic  progress  of  the 

United  States,  1890-1908":  pp.  289-302. 
10-24776  HF1711.A82 

Bourassa,  Henri.     The  reciprocit}^  agreement  and  its  consequences 
as  viewed  from  the  Nationalist  standpoint. 
Montreal:  "-Le  Devoir"",  1911.     ^3  pp.     8°. 

"This  pamphlet  is  a  literal  translation  of  seven  articles  published 
in  "Le  Devoir",  from  January  31st  to  February  7th." 

HF1732.C2B8 

The  Canadian  annual  review  of  public  affairs,  1909.     By  J.  Castell 
Hopkins. 
Toronto:    The  Annual  review  puhlishing   company,   [1910]. 
661  pp.     8°. 

"Treaties,   reciprocity  and   other  United  States  affairs:"     pp. 

621-627. 
5-27179  F1008.C33     1009 

Chapleau,  J.  A,     Discours  au  Club  commercial  de  Providence,  K.  I. 
le  28  novembre  1891.     (Traduction.) 

(In  Bellerive,  Georges,  ed.  Orateurs  caiiadieiis-fran<;aifi  aux 
Ktata-Unis;  conferences  et  discours.  Quebec,  1908.  8°.  pp. 
41-68.) 

Discusses  the  question  of  reciprocity  with  the  United  State^J. 

F1033.B44 

Collins,  I'iuil  y.     Canadian  reciprocity  vs.  .American  niaiiutacturors 
as  well  as  farmers. 
Minneapolis:  P.   V.  Collins  publishing  company.,  [1910].     IJf. 
pp.     16^. 

"  Written  for  Agricultural  advertising  magazine." 


/ 


6  LIBEARY   OF   CONGRESS 

Hill,  James  Jerome.     Highways  of  progress. 

New  Yorl':    Doxihleday ^  Page  &  company^  1910.     x,  353  pp. 

8°. 

Contents. — The  nation's  future. — Agriculture  and  the  national 
life. — Farm  methods — old  and  new. — Reciprocity  with  Can- 
ada.— Commerce. — Industrial  and  railroad  consolidations. — 
The  Northwest. — Oriental  trade. — Irrigation  and  drainage. — 
AVaterways. — The  railroad. — The  conservation  of  capital. — The 
natural  wealth  of  the  land  and  its  conservation. 

10-14659  HC106.H57 

Hobson,  John  Atkinson.     Canada  to-day. 

London:  T.  F.lJnwin.,1906.     xii{.,lJf3.,  {1) pp.     Tables.     12°. 

"Canada's  fiscal  future":  pp.  115-143. 

7-32187  HC115.H8 

Montagu,  Edwin  S.  and  Bron  Herbert.     Canada  and  the  Empire: 
an  examination  of  trade  preferences.     With  a  preface  by 
Rt.  Hon.  the  Earl  of  Rosebery. 
London:  P.  S.  King  i&  son,  1904-     xvUi,  198 jyp-    Diagrams. 

ir. 

Appendix  I  (pp.  131-154)  consists  of  miscellaneous  extracts  from 
various  Canadian  publications.  Appendix  ii  (pp.  155-198)  of 
opinions  expressed  by  representative  Canadians  in  answer  to  a 
series  of  questions  submitted  to  them  by  the  authors. 

Contents. — i.  Canadian  conditions. — ii.  Canada  and  the  United 
States. — III.  Canadian  view  of  English  politics. — iv.  The  results 
of  the  policy. — v.  What  Britain  might  do. — vi.  Conclusion. 

5-8732  HC115.M7 

Porritt,  Edward.     The  revolt  in  Canada  against  the  new  feudalism; 
tariff  history  from  the  revision  of  1907  to  the  uprising  of 
the  West  in  1910. 
London :  Pub.  for  the  Cohden  cluh,  hy  Cassell  and  company^ 
ltd.,  1911.     X,  21,6  pp.     m°. 

Root,  John  William.     Colonial  tariffs. 

Liverpool:  J.   W.  Boot,  1906.     xii,  311,  (1)  pp.     8°. 
Canada  and  Newfoundland:  pp.  206-232. 
6-18062  Hri723.R78 

The  trade  relations  of  the  British  Empire. 

Live)'pool:  J.  W.  Boot,  1903.     xvi,  1,31  jjp.     8°. 

"The  working  of  the  Canadian  preferential  tariff":  pp.  23-62. 
3-26611  HF3506.R78 

Siegfried,  Andre.     The  race  question  in  Canada. 

Lmdon  :  E.  Nash,  1907.     viii,  31,3,  {1)  pp.     8°. 

French  edition,  Paris,  1906,  published  under  title:   Le  Canada,  les 

deux  races;  problemes  politiques  contemporains. 
"The  Liberal  party:  its  economic  policy":  pp.  197-205. 
7-22822  F1033.S58 


RECIPEOCITY    WITH    CANADA  7 

Smart,  William.     The  return  to  protection;  being-  a  re-statement  of 
the  case  for  free  trade.     2d  ed. 
London,  New  YorJt :  Macmillan  and  co.,  limited^  1906.     xlv^ 
297,  {1)  pp.     8°. 
First  edition,  1904. 
Based  upon  a  series  of  lectures  delivered  to  popular  audiences  in 

Glasgow  and  Edinburgh,  during  Feb.  and  Mar.  1904. 
"The  Canadian  preference":  pp.  226-234. 
8-10475  Hr2046.S625 

Smith,  Goldwin.     Reminiscences;  ed.  by  Arnold  Haul  tain. 

JVew   York :     The  Macmillan  company,  1910.      xv,  4-77  pp. 
Frontispiece.     Plate.     Portraits.     8^. 

10-30096  F1033.S65 

Tariff  com.missioii,  London.    The  proposed  reciprocal  trade  arrange-    ^ 
ment  between  Canada  and  the  United  States  of  America. 
2d  ed. 
London:  P.  S.  King  cfc  Son,  [1911].     38pp.     .4°. 

HF1732.C2T2. 

Trescher,  Erich.     Vorzugszolle.     Ihre  Geschichte  und  Wirkung  im 
internationalen  Waronaustausch. 
Berlin:  F.  Siernenroth,  1908.     vii,  176  pp.     8°. 

10-30584  Hri721.T7 

Young,  James.  Public  men  and  public  life  in  Canada,  being  recol- 
lections of  Parliament  and  the  press,  and  embracing  a  suc- 
cinct account  of  the  stirring  events  which  led  to  the  con- 
federation of  British  North  America  into  the  Dominion  of 
Canada. 
Toronto:  W.  Brigr/s,  1902.  JfiG  pp.  Frontispiece.  Plates. 
Portraits.     12°. 

"Reciprocity    vainly   .sacrificed   on   the  annexation   altar":  pp. 

288-296. 
3-17  F1032.Y67 

86450°— 11 2 


ARTICLES   IN   PERIODICALS 

1909.  Mann,  D.  D.     Canada  and  reciprocity. 

Saturday  evening  post,  Apr.  21^,  1909^  v.  181:  W,  62. 

Favors  reciprocity.  AP2.S2,v.l81 

1910.  Canadian    trade    agreements.      By    recent    orders-in- council 

special  tariff  arrangements  have  been  made  with  Belgium 
and  Ital}^,  whereby  many  articles  from  these  countries  get 
the  benefit  of  the  intermediate  schedule. 
Industrial  Canada,  July,  1910.,  i\  10:  1182-1184. 

1910.     The  West  and  the  tariff.      Some  considerations  that  should 
enter  into  a  discussion  of  Canada's  tariff  problem.     [Edi- 
torial]. 
Industrial  Canada.,  Sept.  1910,  v.  11:  123-12^. 

1910.     Ross,  Sir  George  W.     A  talk  about  reciprocity. 

Industrial  Canada,  Oct.  1910,  v.    11:  2Jt.7-2JfS. 
Reproduced  from  the  Globe,  Toronto. 

1910.     Canadian  manufacturers'  association.     Report  of  tariff  com- 
mittee; [presented  at  annual  meeting,  Sept.  20-22, 1910]. 
Industrial  Canada,  Oct.  1910,  v.  11:  278-293. 

"Trade  relations  with  the  United  States :"  pp.  280-282. 

1910.     Hopkins,  John  Castell.     Canadian  reciprocity  with  the  United 
States. 

National  revieiv,  Oct.  1910,  v.  56:  320-333.         AP4.N25,v.66 

1910.     Opposes   reciprocity   treaty;    Sir   Geo.    W.  Ross,  in   speech 
before  Toronto  Board  of  trade,  urges  many  reasons  why 
Canada  should  not  sign  a  trade   treaty  with  the   United 
States. 
Industrial  Canada,  Nov.  1910,  v.  11:  If-Jt-l-lflfB. 
Text  of  speech. 

1910.     Foster,   George   E.      Reciprocity:    Why   the   United   States 
wants  it. 
Canadian  magazine,  Dec.  1910,  v.  36:  193-195.       AP5.C2,v.36 

1910.     McArthur,  Peter.     Reciprocity  with  Canada. 

Forum,  Dec.  1910,  v.  U-'  655-662.  AP2.F8,v.44 


EECIPROCITY    WITH    CANADA  \) 

1910.     Reciprocity^  would  draw  much  U.  S.  capital  from  our  industries. 
Industrial  Canada,  Dec.  1910,  v.  if:  530-51^0. 

"At  present  it  is  estimated  that  $233,000,000  of  U.  S.  money  is 
employed  in  Canada,  giving  work  to  many  thousands  of  indus- 
trial operations."  See  article  on  United  States  investments  in 
Canadian  industrial  enterprises,  in  Monetary  times,  Nov.  13, 
1909,  V.  43,  pp.  2011-2015,  2025-2026.  HFl.M66,v.43 

1910.  NesWtt,    Wallace.       Canada's    attitude    toward    reciprocit}'. 

Prosperity  of  Canada  during  previous  reciprocity  treaty 
with  United  States  was  result  of  immense  demand  for  farm 
products  during  civil  war.  Canada  should  protect  her 
investments  in  east  and  west  transportation  s3'stems.  The 
position  of  the  farmers. 
Industrial  Canada,  Dec.  1910,  v.  11:  5]^l-5Ji.If.. 

Address  delivered  before  the  Canadian  club,  Toronto. 

1911.  Canada  for  free  trade.     [Editorial]. 

Nation,  {london),  Dec.  21^,  1910,  v.  8:  527-529.     AP4.S67,v.8 
On  the  presentation  in  the  Canadian  House  of  Commons  of  a 
memorial  by  800  representatives  of  the  National  council  of  agri- 
culture, favoring  free  trade  with  Great  Britain  and  reciprocity 
with  the  United  States. 

1910.     Farmers  and  the  Dominion  gov'ernment. 

Outlool\  Dec.  SI,  1910,  v.  90:  99^-995.  AP2.08,v.96 

Attitude  of  Canadian  farmers  toward  reciprocity  with  the  United 
States. 

1910.  Foster,  George  E.     Reciprocity  with  the  United  States. 

University  magazine,  Dec.  1910,  v.  9:  550-562.     LHl.P3U6,v.O 

1911.  McGrath,  P.  T.     Will  there  be  reciprocity  between  the  United 

States  and  Canada:? 
American  revieio  of  reviews,  Jan.  1911,  r.  J^J:  Jf.2-Jf/). 

AP2.N7,v.43 

1911.     The  reciprocity  negotiations. 

Canadian  gazette,  Jan.  12, 1911,  v.  56:  J,71.        HCl ll.C2,v.66 

1911.     The  rcciprocit}'  question. 

Canadian  gazeffr,  Jan.  26,  1911,  r.  56:  54.J.         HClll.C2,v.66 
Newspaper  and  otlicr  coinmciit. 

1911.     The  reciprocity  negotiations. 

Canadian  jiiuriuilof  caninwrce,  Jan.  20,  191  l,r.  72:  79. 

<^)ppose(l  to  rocii)r()rity.  HFl.C2,v.72 

1911.      Hill,  .lanios  ,J.     Trade   reriprocity  botwoon  Canada  and  the 
Tnitcd  States, 
Kditorial  revicn-,  Jan.  1911,  v.  J^:  lJ^-21.  AP2.E26,v.4 


10  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

1911.     Farmers'  tariff  deputation  at  Ottawa.     East  joins  West  in  the 
free  trade  deiuand. 
Free  trader,  Jan.  19,  1911:  11-15.         HF2040.F8,Jan.l9,1911 
Extracts  from  Canadian  newspapers. 

1911.     Porritt,  Edward.    The  insurgent  movement  in  Canada. 

Independent,  Jan.  19,  1911,  v.  70:  131^-137.  AP2.I53,v.70 

On  the  tariff  policy  of  the  Liberal  party  and  the  movement  of 
agricultural  organizations  in  favor  of  freer  trade  with  Great 
Britain  and  the  United  States. 

1911.     Young,  Lafayette.     Reciprocity  in  protection. 

Indepen den t,  Jan .  ^6,  1911,  v.  70:  1 76-1 79.  AP2.I53, v.70 

1911.     Russell,  T.  A.     The  grain  growers  and  the  manufacturers. 
Industrial  Canada,  Jan.  1911.,  v.  11:  637-6j^2. 

"Mr.  Russell  shows  the  fallacy  of  the  grain  growers'  contentions 
that  they  suffer  unduly  from  the  tariff,  and  proves  that  farmers 
themselves  are  not  unanimously  in  favor  of  a  reduction.  What 
the  home  markets  mean." 

1911.     Trade  agreement  with  United  States. 

Monetary  times,  Jan.  28,  1911,  v.  1^6:  1^19.  Hri.M66,v.46 

1911.     America,  Canada,  and  Great  Britain.     [Editorial]. 

Nation,  {London),  Jan.  28,1911,  v.  8:  707-708.       AP4.S67,v.8 
Reprinted  in  Living  age,  Feb.  25,  1911,  v.  50,  pp.  491-492. 

AP2.L65,v.50 
1911.     Reciprocity  and  the  Union. 

Outlook,  (London),  Jan.  7,  1911,  v.  25:  6-7.        AP4.08,v.25 

1911.     Canadian  "reciprocity",  nos.  1-5.     [Editorials]. 

Bural  New-York(fi\^ Feb.  18,  25,  Mar.  4,  11,  18,  1911,  v.  70: 
201,;  21fi;  280;  321,;  361,.  Sl.R9,v.70 

Opposed. 

1911.  The  Canadian  agreement:  So-called  reciprocity  bargain  in 
which  the  United  States  agrees  to  a  wholesale  system  of 
free  trade  in  products  of  the  farm,  the  mine,  the  forest  and 
the  fisheries,  while  receiving  from  Canada  some  trivial 
tariff  concessions  on  exports  of  American  manufacture. 
American  economist,  Feb.  3,  1911,  v.  1^7 :  62-66. 

HC101.A5,v.47 
1911.     Proposed  reciprocity  with  Canada. 

American  industries,  Feb.  1911,  v.  11:  23-25. 

HD4802.A6,v.ll 
"A  complete  table  of  the  articles  included  in  the  provisions  of  the 
proposed  reciprocity  agreement  is  published  herewith,  together 
with  the  following  analysis,  for  the  information  of  the  mem- 
bers of  the  National  association  of  manufacturers,  many  of 
whose  products  would  be  affected." 


RECIPKOCITY   WITH   CANADA  11 

1911.     The  tariff  agreement.     [Editorial]. 

Canada^  Fth.  ^,  1911,  v.  21:  135.  Fl00l.Cl5,v.21 

1911.     The  reciprocity  agreement:  free  trade  in  natural  products. 

Canada,  Feb.  li.,  1911,  V. '21:  137-138.  Fi001.C15,v.21 

1911.     Reciprocity,  preference  and  imperialism.     [Editorial]. 

Canada,  Feb.  11,  1911,  v.  21:  166-167.  Fl001.C15,v.21 

1911.     Reciprocity  and  lo3^alty:  speeches  at  the  London  Canada  club, 
Feb.  15,  1911. 
Canada,  Feb.  25,  1911,  v.  21:  223.  Fl00l.ci5,v.21 

1911.     Trade  reciprocity.     The  agreement  between  Canada  and  the 
United  States. 
Canadian  gazette^  Feb.  2,  1911,  v.  56:  578-579. 

HClll.C2,v.56 
Details  of  the  agreement  and  newspaper  comment. 

1911.     The  meaning  of  the  Washington  deal,     [Editorial]. 
^Canadian  gazette,  Feb.  2,  1911,  v.  56:  590-591. 

HClll.C2,v.66 

1911.     Mr.  Fielding  and  British  unionists.     [Editorial]. 
Canadian  gazette,  Feb.  9,  1911,  v.  56:  609-610. 

HClll.C2,v.56 

On  the  relation  of  the  reciprocity  agreement  with  the  United 
States  to  the  policy  of  Canatlian  preference  to  imports  from 
Great  Britain. 

1911.     The  conflict  of  ideals.     [Editorial]. 

Canadian  gazette,  Feb.  9,  1911,  v.  56:  626-627. 

HClll.C2,v.56 

On  the  reciprocity  agreement  between  Canada  and  the  United 
States. 

1911.     The  reciprocity  agreement.     Mr.   Fielding  on  the  countries 
affected. 
Canadian  gazette,  Feh.  23,  lUll,  r.  56:  688-689. 

HClll.C2,v.66 

1911.     Plain  answers  to  plain  (juestioiis.     |  Editorinl  on  the  reciprocity 
agreement  J. 
Canadian  gazette,  Feb.  23,  191 1,  r.  56:  700-701. 

HClll.C2,v.66 

1911.     TJio  rcciprocul  tariff  proposals.     [Editorial]. 

Canadian  journal  of'  coinmti'ce,  Feb.  3,  1911,  /'.  72:    150-151. 
Opposed. 

HFl.C2,v.72 


12  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

1911.     Fish  under  the  reciprocity  proposals.     [Editorial]. 

Canadian  journal  of  coTninei'ce,  Feb.  17.,  1911,  v.  I'B. 

Hri.C2,v.72 

1911.     U.  8.  trade  proposals.     [Editorial]. 

Canadian  journal  of  commerce.,  Feb.  '2Ii.,  1911,  v.  72:  259-260. 
Opposed  to  the  reciprocity  agreement.  HFl.C2,v.72 

1911.     Edmonds,  W.  L.     Reciprocity  question  undermining  Canadian 
contidence. 
Canadian  Manufacturer,  Feb.  1911,  v.  31:  39-Jf.l. 

TSl.C22,v.31 

1911.     The  vote  on  reciprocit}^  in  the  House.     [Editorial]. 

Commercial  and  financial  chronicle,   Feb.  18,  1911,  v.   92: 
J,18~Jfl9.  HGl.C7,v.92 

1911.     Lysaght,  John.     The   Canadian   agreement  and   the   British 
sheet  iron  industry. 

Commercicd  intelligence,  Feb.  22,  1911,  v.  23:  2If.. 

Letter  to  the  London  Times.  HFll.C7,v.23 

1911.     Kingman,  R.  T.     A  letter  addressed  to  Hon.  A.  J.  Gronna, 
Feb.  16,  1911,  with  reference  to  reciprocity  with  Canada. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4-6,  no.  60  {current 
file):  3203-320 If. 

Opposed  to  reciprocity. 

1911.     Tariff  reform  and  the  reciprocity  agreement.     [Editorial]. 

Economist,  Feh.  If.,  1911,  v.  62:  201^-205.  HGll.E2,v.62 

1911.     North  American  reciprocity  examined.     [Editorial]. 

Economist,  Feb.  11,  1911,  v.  62:  256-257.  HGll.E2,v.62 

1911.     Canadian  reciprocitj^  and  trade  with  Britain.     [Washington 
correspondence]. 
Economist,  Feb.  18,  1911,  v.  62:  318.  HGll.E2,v.62 

1911.     A    Canadian   view    of     reciprocit}'^.      [Correspondence    from 
Ottawa]. 
Economist,  Feb.  25,  1911,  v.  72:  376-377.  hgii.E2,v.72 

1911.     The  "fairy  wand"  in  North  America.     [Editorial  comment  on 
the  Canadian  reciprocity  agreement]. 
Free  tradei\  Feb.  16,  1911:  62-65.       HF2040.F8,Feb.l6,l911 

1911.     The  trade  agreement  with  Canada.     [Editorial]. 

Independent,  Feb.  2,  1911,  v.  70:  265-267.  AP2.I63,v.70 


KECIPROCITY   WITH   CANADA  13 

1911.     The  agreement  with  Canada.     [Editorial], 

Independent,  Feb.  16,  1911,  v.  70:  365-367.  AP2..T53,v.70 

1911.     Mr.  Clark  waves  the  flag.     [Editorial]. 

Independent,  Feh.  23,  1911,  v.  70:  Jfl5-Ji.l7.  AP2.I53,v.70 

1911.  Oppose  change  in  existing  tariff  conditions.  Strong  bod}-  of 
manufacturers  representing  interests  from  coast  to  coast, 
present  memorial  to  government  setting  forth  their 
grounds  for  opposing  grain  growers'  demands  for  reduc- 
tion in  tariff'. 

Industrial  Canada,  Feh.  1911,  v.  11:  735-74,2. 

Text  of  memorial  presented  to  Sir  "Wilfrid  Laurier  by  the  Canadian 
manufacturers'  association. 

1911.     Skelton,  O.  D.     Reciprocity:  the  Canadian  attitude. 

Journal  of  political  economy,  Feb.  1911,  v.  19:  77-97. 

HBl.J7,v.l9 
1911.     Canada  and  the  United  States. 

Liberal  magazine,  Feb.  1911,  v.  19:16-21.    JNll29.L4L4,v.l9 

1911.     Proposed  tariff'  arouses  great  interest.     Some  facts,  figures, 
and  opinions  which  will  enable  the  discussion  to  be  followed 
more  easily. 
Monetary  timex,  Feb.  Jf.,  1911,  v.  1^.6:5 1^-5 19.      HFl.M66,v.46 

1911.     Reciprocity  debate.     Arguments  for  and  against  a  protective 
tariff.     Mr.  E.  C.  Drury  and  Mr.  T.  A.  Russell  have  interest- 
ing discussion  at  Beaverton. 
Monetary  times,  Feb.  4,  1911,  v.  1^6:526.  HFi.M66,v.46 

1911.     Proposed  tariff  and  its  principle.     Reasons  for  guarded  action. 
Manufacturers'  anah\sis  of  pi'oposal.     Some  views  of  the 
agreement. 
Monetary  times,  Feb.  11,  1911,  v.  Jii6:616-tilS.    HFl.M66,v.46 

1911.     Manufacturers  oppose  tariff  changes.     They  look  witli  anxiety 
at  the  growing  American  exports  of  n)anufactures. 
Nondnry  thnt-x,  Fb.  IS,  1911,  v.  Jfi:  717.  Fl.M66,v.46 

1911.     Other  countiics  may  seek  advantage's.      Wasliinglon  views  of 
the  favored-nation  clause.     How  the  agreement  will  work. 
Monetary  times,  Feb.  IS,  1911,  v.  Jfi:  717-718. 

HF1.M66.V.46 

1911.     Trade  tics  and  annexation.     Lessons  of  tlie  past.     Agreement 
is  not  in  the  country's  interest.     Will  seriousi}'  check  trade. 
Monetary  times,  I,h.  25,  1911,  v.  Ji.6:  816-817. 

HFl.M66,v.46 


14  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

1911.     The  downfall  of  colonial  preference.     [Editorial]. 

Nation^  {London),  Feh.  \,  1911,  v.  8:  753-75Jt..       AP4.S67,v.8 

1911.     Canada  and  wheat  prices.     [Editorial]. 

JVatian,  {Londo?i) ,  Feh.  11, 1911,  v.  8:  793-794-.       AP4. S67, v.8 

1911.     The  tariff  reform  attack  on  Canada.     [Editorial]. 

Nation, {London),  Feh.  18,  191 1 ,  v.  8:  825-826.       AP4.S67,v.8 

1911.     McCulloch,  John.     Will  freer  trade  make  dearer  wheat? 

Nation,  {London),  Feh.  18,  1911,  v.  8:  8Ifi.  AP4.S67,v.8 

Argues  that  the  Canadian  reciprocity  agreement  will  not  raise 
the  price  of  wheat  in  Europe. 

1911.     The  President  on  freer  trade.     [Editorial]. 

Nation,  {Neto  Tori")  Feh.  2,  1911,  v.  92:  106.       AP2.N2,v.92 

1911.     A  really  national  policy.     [Editorial]. 

Nation,  {NewTwh),  Feh.  9,  1911,  v.  92:  132.       ap2.N2,v.92 
"There  can  be  no  doubt  that  the  negotiators  who,  under  Presi- 
dent Taft's  direction,  worked  out  the  Canadian  agreement  did 
so  on  the  basis  of  a  broadly  conceived  national  measure." 

1911.     Canada's  free  hand.     [Editorial]. 

Natimi,  {New  YorTc),  Feh.  16,  1911,  v.  92:  158-159. 

AP2.N2.V.92 

1911.     Reciprocity  and  the  farmers.     [Editorial]. 

Nation,  {New  York),  Feh.  23,  1911,  v.  92:  18^-185. 

AP2.N2,v.92 

1911.     MacVeagh,  Wayne.     An  appeal  to  President  Taft. 

North  American  revieio,  Feh.  1911,  v.  193:  161-179. 

Reciprocity  with  Canada:  pp.  164-165.  AP2.N7,v.l93 

1911.     Laws-on,  W.  R.     The  Canadian  railways  and  reciprocity. 
Outlooh,  {London),  Feh.  18,  1911,  v.  '27:  217-218. 

AP4.08,v.27 
1911.     Canadian  reciprocity.     [Editorial]. 

OutlooTi,  {New  YorJc),  Feh.  4,  1911,  v.  97:  2U-245- 

AP2.08,v.97 

1911.     Canadian  reciprocity  would  help  our  farmers.     [Editorial]. 
Outlook,  {New  York),  Feh.  25,  1911,  v.  97:  372*-374''. 

AP2.08,v.97 

1911.     Brigham,  E.  S.     A  farmer  on  reciprocity.     [Letter  to  Repre- 
sentative D.  J.  Foster,  of  Vermont]. 
Bural  New-Yorker,  Feh.  18,  1911,  v.  70:  189.         sl.R9,v.70 
Opposed. 


EECIPKOCITY   WITH   C  AX  ADA  15 

1911.     Reciprocit}'  and  annexation.     [Editorial]. 

Shipping  icorld^  Feb.  22,  1911,  v.  ^^.'  ^Olf..         HE561.S6,v.44 

1911.     Hildebrand,    Gerhard.     Was    bedeutet    das    kanadisch-nord- 
amerikanische  Handels- Abkommen  \ 
Sozialistische  Monatshefte,  Feb.  23,  1911,  v.  4,:  232-2^0. 

HX6.S6,v.4 
1911.     Reciprocity  and  the  empire.     [Editorial]. 

Spectator,  Feb.  4-,  1911,  v.  106:  174-175.  AP4.S7,v.l06 

1911.     Canadian  commerce  and  British  politics.     [Editorial]. 

Spectator,  Feh.  11,  1911,  v.  106:  206-207.  AP4.S7,v.l06 

1911.     Canada  and  the  United  States — The  real  danger.     [Editorial]. 
Sx'tctator,  Feb.  18,  1911,  v.  106:  24J-2U-  AP4.S7,v.l06 

1911.     The  American-Canadian  treatj^. 

Statist,  Feb.  4,  1911,  v.  67:  217.  HGll.S8,v.67 

1911.     The  Canadian  Parliament  on  annexation.     [Editorial]. 

Statist,  Feb.  25,  1911,  v.  67:  363-364.  HGll.S8,v.67 

1911.     Tariff  revision  by  reciprocity. 

American  banker.  Mar.  18,  1911,  v.  76:  839-840. 

HG1501.A5,v.76 

1911.     Dodge,  Arthur  J.     Sudden  fondness  for  reciprocity:    Demo- 
crats favor  it  now  because  it  "puts  the  Republican  party 
in  a  hole". 
American  economist.  Mar.  24-,  1911,  v.  4'^-   158-159. 

HC101.A5,v.47 

1911.     Current  newspaper  comments:    what  the  editors  are  saying 
about  the  proposed  Canadian  agreement. 
American  economist.  Mar.  24.,  1911,  v.  4^ •'   164-167. 

HC101.A5,v.47 

1911.     The  Democrats  and  Canadian  reciprocity.     |  Kditoriiilj. 

Argonaut,  M'/r.  18.  1911,  v.  6S:  103.  AP2.A65,v.68 

1911.     Problems  of  the  Canada-United  States  agreement. 
/Jritis/,.  trade  joHrmd,  Mar.  1,  1911,  v.  J(S):  80-81. 

HFll.B7,v.49 

1911.     Reciprocity  and  imperialism. 

Ctniada,  Afar.  4,  1911,  v.  21:  258-259.  Fl001.Cl5,v.21 

1911.     The  reciprocity  agreement:    its  ctlects  on   the   fruit  giowing 
inclustry. 
Canada,  M>ir.  4.  191 1,  r.  21:  264.  F1001.Cl6,v.2I 

864.50^— J 1 3 


16  LIBEARY   OF   CONGRESS 

1911.     Another  view  of  the  reciprocity  agreement. 

Canada,  Mar.  ,^,  1911,  v.  21:  265.  F1001.ci5,v.21 

1911.     The  reciprocity  agreement.     Mr.  Sifton's  opposition. 
Canadian  gazette,  Mar.  2,  1911,  v.  56:  726-727. 

HClll.C2,v.56 

1911.     Mr.  Griffith  at  Birmingham  university:  a  good  word  for  John 
Bull — The    Washington    compact    and     Canada's     future 
destiny. 
Canadian  gazette.  Mar.  2,  1911,  v.  56:  7 SO.       HClll.C2,v.66 

1911.     Some  imperial  aspects  of  the  reciprocity  arrangement. 
Canadian  gazette,  Mar.  2,  1911,  v.  56:  7JiZ-7Ji.Ii.. 

HClll.C2,v.56 

1911.     The  reciprocity  agreement. 

Canadian  gazette.  Mar.  23,  1911,  v.  56:  8Jt.8-8Jt.9. 

Newspaper  and  other  comment.  HClll.C2,v.56 

1911.     Edmonds,  W.  L.     The  business  aspect  of  reciprocity. 
Canadian  manufacturer.  Mar.  1911,  v,  31:  Ji.3-Jt,Ji.. 

TSl.C22,v.31 

"The  question  should  be  considered  from  a  business  standpoint 
and  not  clouded  by  theoretical  economists.  The  agreement 
now  before  Parliament  has  not  been  so  considered  and  much 
of  the  information  supplied  the  negotiating  ministers  was 
inadequate.  A  mandate  should  be  obtained  from  the  people 
before  the  agreement  is  ratified." 

1911.     Reciprocity  and  municipalities.     [Editorial]. 

Canadian  municipal  journal.  Mar.  1911,  v.  7:  93. 

HD4421.C3,v.7 

Opposed  to  reciprocity  with  the  United  States. 

1911.     [Reciprocity  witii  Canada.] 

Car  rent  literature.  Mar.  1911,  v.  50:  231-2 JfJf.. 

AP2.C96,v.50 

1911.     Canadian  preference  and  reciprocity.     [Canadian  correspond- 
ence]. 
Economist,  Mar.  J^.,  1911,  v.  72:  J4.28-J4.29.  HGll.E2,v.72 

1911.     Dicey,    Edward.     Foreign    affairs:  Canada   and    the    United 
States. 

Empire  reviev),  Mar.  1911,  v.  21:  73-75.  DAio.E5,v.2l 

1911.     Mond,  Sir  Alfred.     The  Canadian- American  reciprocity  agree- 
ment. 

English  review.  Mar.  1911,  v.  7:  731-7 JfJ/..  AP4.E523,v.7 

Reprinted  in  Living  age,' Apr.  8,  1911,  v.  269,  pp.  69-76. 

AP2.L65,v.269 


RECIPROCITY   WITH   CAXADA  17 

1911.     Garvin,  J.  L.     Imperial  union  and  American  reciprocity. 

Fortnightly  review^  liar.  1911,  v.  89:  0S8-4O4,. 

AP4.F7,v.89 

1911.     Johnston,  Charles.     Mr.  Taft  and  reciprocity:  an  authorized 
expression  of  the  President's  views  on  the  dominant  ques- 
tion of  the  hour. 
jSarper^s  weekly.  Mar.  ^,  1911,  v.  55:  8-9.  AP2.H28,v.55 

1911.     The  Canadian  reciprocity  treaty. 

Journal  of  political  economy,  Mar.  1911,  v.  19:  233-238 . 

HBl.J7,v.l9 

1911.     Hughes,  Hugh  J.     Reciprocity:  wh}' the  farmer  objects. 

Za  FoUette's  weekly  magazine.  Mar.  11, 1911,  v.  3:  7-9;  12-13. 

AP2.L28,v.3 

1911.     The  fiscal  amendment.     [Debate  in  the  House  of  Commons]. 

Liberal  magazine,  Mar.  1911,  v.  20:  99-106. 

JN1129.L4L4,  v.20 

"The  fiscal  amendment  to  the  Address  which  Mr.  Austen  Cham- 

l)erlain  moved  was  almost  entirely  concerned  with  the  proposed 

reciprocity  agreement  between  Canada  and  the  United  States." 

1911.     The  recipi'ocity  agreement.     [Comment  on  tlie  attitude  of  the 
British  Conservatives]. 
Liberal  magazine.  Mar.  191U  v.  20:  107-109. 

JNl  129. L4L4,  v.20 
1911.     Canada  on  her  dignity. 

Lit&ra/ry  digest.  Mar.  11,  1911,  v.  Jt.2:  Jf50-Jf62. 

AP2.L68,v.42 
Extracts  from  Canadian  newspapers  and  speeches  opposing  the 
reciprocity  agreement. 

1911,     Americans  will  not  cstaV)lish  branches  in  Canada  if  the  pro- 
posed agreement  is  ratihed — liCssons  of  the  past — Mr.  8if- 
ton  breaks  from  party. 
Monetary  times,-Mar.  4,  1911,  r.  Jf(J:  918.  hfi.M66,v.46 

1911.     Lessons  of  the  past.     Tariff  and  coin])Ietc  reciprocity  can  not 
co-exist  permanently  between  two  nations,  says  Mr.  E.  B. 
Biggar. 
Monetary  times,  Mar.  J^,  1911,  v.  ^0:  919.  HFl.M66,v.46 

Summary  of  a  jjamphlct  by  this  writer. 

1911.     Ueciprocit}'   agreement    will    sacrilice   Canada's  national   and 
imperial  interests — An)ericaii  \  icws  are  significant. 
Moxetiiry  tiineft.  Mar.  11,  1911,  v.  40:  1015-1016. 

HFl.M66,v.46 


18  LIBEAEY   OF   CONGRESS 

1911.     Taft  is  frank  regarding  desire  for  Canadian  market  for  Amer- 
ican manufactures — Utterances  of  United  States  journals 
are  significant. 
Monetary  tlmes^  Mar.  ^5,  1911.,  v.  Ii,6:  1212.       KFl.M66,v.46 

1911.     Commercial  independence  or  commercial  union — which?    Hon. 
Clifford  Sifton,  m.   p.,  condemns  reciprocity  agreement — 
Enthusiastic  meeting  at  Montreal. 
Monetary  times.  Mar.  25,  1911,  v.  1^6:  1213,  121^1. 

R6sum6  of  Mr.  Sifton's  speech.  HFl.M66,v.46 

1911.     Tariff  commission  of  Great  Britain  has  issued  memorandum 
respecting  proposed  agreement — Interesting  facts  and  fig- 
ures. 
Monetary  times.  Mar.  25,  1911,  v.  J^Q:  1213.       HFl.M66,v.46 
Summary  of  the  memorandum;  for  its  title  see  book  list,  under 
Tariff  commission. 

1911.     Selke,  David  Louis.     The  reciprocity  bill:   its   prospects  of 
passage  at  the  extra  session  of  Congress. 
Moody's  magazine.  Mar.  1911,  v.  11:  203-20 J^. 

HGl.M85,v.ll 

1911.     Allum,  T.  C.     Canada  and  reciprocity. 

Moody's  magazine,  Mar.  1911,  v.  11:  205-206. 

HGl.M85,v.ll 
1911.     The  case  for  reciprocity.     [Editorial]. 

Nation,  {London),  Mar.  11,  1911,  v.  8:  95Jf-955. 

AP4.S67,v.8 

1911.     Reciprocity  with  Canada — Views  of  Secretary  Knox  and  J.  J. 
Hill. 

National  land  and  irrigation  journal.  Mar.  1911,  v.  3:  IJf.. 

Extracts  from  and  comment  on  their  addresses  before  the  Chicago 
association  of  commerce. 

1911.     Carman,  Albert  R.     Canada  and  American  reciprocity. 

National  review.  Mar.  1911,  v.  57:  68-74-.  AP4.N25,v.57 

1911.     Low,  Maurice  A.     American  affairs. 

National  review.  Mar.  1911,  v.  57:  110-121.       AP4.N25,v.57 
Discusses  the  reciprocity  agreement. 

1911.    Canadian  affairs. 

National  revieiv.  Mar.  1911,  v.  57:  157-161.       ap4.N25,v.67 
Discusses  the  reciprocity  agreement. 

1911.     Bachelder,  N.  J.     Appeal  to  the  President.     Master  of  the 
National  grange  says  Canadian  reciprocity  will  result  in 
injury  to  farmers  and  depreciation  of  farm  lands. 
Neu)  Tfrrk  trihune  farmer.  Mar.  23,  1911,  v.  10:  2. 

Letter  dated  Feb.  28,  1911.  Sl.N68,v.lO 


EECIPEOCITY   WITH   CANADA  19 

1911.     Cook,  Herbert  E,     The  reciprocity  treaty.     A  strong  plea  for 
the  American  farmer — the  attitude   of   the   Grange  sup- 
ported. 
New  York  trihune  farrnei\  Mar.  23,  1911,  v.  10:  2,  16. 

Sl.N68,v.lO 

1911.     Lethbridge,  Roper.     The  Liberal  policy  of  imperial  disinte- 
gration. 
Nineteenth  century  and  afte^\  Mar.  1911,  v.  69:  381-Jf.Ol. 

AP4.N7,v.69 
Discusses  the  attitude  of  the  Liberal  party  in  Great  Britain  toward 
Canada  and  Canadian  tariff  policies. 

1911.     Petition  again.st  Canadian  free  trade  on  farm  products,  with 
protection  on  what  farmers  bu}-. 
Ncrrthwestern  agriculturist.  Mar.  11,  1911,  r.  26:  SlfJ^-SJio. 

Sl.N85,v.26 

Reprinted  in  American  economist,  Mar.  24,  1911,  v.  47,  pp.  147- 
151,  156-157.  HC101.A6,v.47 

1911.     The  struggle  over  reciprocit3\     [Editorial]. 

Outlool;  {London),  Mar.  11,  1911,  v.  27:  303-304. 

AP4.08,v.27 

1911.     ]\Iarvin,  Thomas  O.     American  interests  and  industries:  facts 
and  figures  showing  how  important  pi'oducts  may  be  inju- 
riousl}^  affected  b\^  reciprocity  with  Canada. 
Protectionist,  Mar.  1911,  v.  22:  575-578.         HFl750.P8,v.22 

1911.     Marvin,  Thomas  O.    The  Canadian  agreement.    Un-Amorican, 
un-wise,  indefensible. 
Protectionist,  Mar.  1911,  v.  22:  579-58 J,..         hf1750.P8,v.22 

1911.     The  campaign  for  reciprocity.     A  brief  review  of  the  progress 
of  the  Canadian  pact  from  January  2G  to  February  18. 
Protectiovixt,  Mar.  1911,  v.  22:  593-601.         HF1750.P8,v.22 

1911.     Reciprocity  witli  Canada:    j Special  message  of  the  President, 
correspondence  with  the  Canadian  govoniment  and  pro- 
posed rates  of  dut\']. 
Protectionist,  Mar.  1911,  v.  22:  601-612.         HF1760.P8,v.22 

1911.      l'>overidge,  Albert  r7.     Canadiiin   reciprocity:  i(s   inllucncc  on 
the  cost  of  living. 
/Saturday  evening  /'o.sf.  Mar.  25,  1911,  v.  183:  3-5,  53-5If.. 

AP2.S2,v.l83 

1911.      riio  reciprocity  indictment.     [  P^ditorial]. 

Saturday  revieir.  Mar.  11,  1911,  v.  3:  290-292.         AP4.S3,v.3 


20  LIBEARY    OF   CONGRESS 

1911.     Canadian-American  reciprocity.     [Editorial]. 

Spectator,  Mar.  ^,  1911,  r.  106:  317-318.  AP4.S7,v.l06 

1911.     The  reciprocity  arrangement,     i.  Its  advantages  to  the  United 
States.     II.  Its  advantages  to  Canada,     iii.  Its  advantages 
to  Great  Britain.     [Editorials]. 
Statist,  Mar.  Ji.-18,  1911,  v.  67:  Ji25-Ji27 ,  1^91-4^2,  6]t5-51^7, 

HGll.S8,v.67 

1911.     The  proposed  reciprocity  treaty  with  Canada,     [Editorial]. 

Twentieth  century  'magazine.  Mar.  1911,  v.  3:  5Jf3-6If5. 

AP2.T88,v.3 

1911.     Fenwick,  C.  B.     Canadian  reciprocity  and  Pan-Americanism. 

WorlcTs  worl,  {London),  Mar.  1911,  v.  17:  367-371. 

AP4.W85,v.l7 

"A  statement  of  the  case  against  the  agreement  of  Washington 
from  an  imperial  standpoint — the  triumph  of  Mr.  Taft  and  his 
Pan-American  policy." 

1911.     Reciprocity  and  lumber;  a  statement  based  on  official  reports. 

American  review  of  reviews,  Apr.  1911,  v.  4^:  Jf.69-It.70. 

AP2.R4,v.43 

1911.     Walker,  Thomas  B.     Timber  conservation  a,s  related  to  reci- 
procity. 

American  review  of  reviews,  Apr.  1911,  v.  Jf^:  J{70-^7'2. 

AP2.B4,v.43 

1911.     Reciprocity  the  hope  of  the  consumer. 

Centurij  magazine,  Ayr.  1911,  v.  81:  951-952.      AP2.C4,v.81 

1911.     Porritt,  Edward.     The  reciprocit}^  agreement  and  British  col- 
onial policy. 
Worth  American  review,  Apr.  1911,  v.  193:  515-522. 

AP2.N7,v.l93 


SPEECHES    IN  CONGRESS 

Debate  in  the  House  of  Representatives  on  the  bill  (H.  R.  32216)  "To 
promote  reciprocal  trade  relations  with  the  Dominion  of  Canada 
and  for  other  purposes."  Feb.  11, 13-18,  20-25,  27-28;  Mar.  1,  2, 6, 
7,  1911. 

Congressional  record^  61st  Cong.  3d  sess. ,  v.  ^6',  nos.  50^  52-57, 

59-64,  66-69,  72-73  {current  file):  2Jt83-2JtS6;  25^7-2572; 

2618-2650;    2657-2673;    2730-2741;    2850-2854;    ^858; 

2921-2927;    2929-2931;    2934-2944;     3044-301,8;    3053- 

3057;     3073-3075;    3085-3092;    3184-3192;    3265-3269; 

3274-3276;    3327-3334;    3393-3399;    3413-3418;    3430- 

3434;    34B7-3438;    3544-3547;    3661-3667;    3757-3759; 

3911-3913;  4002-4004;  45 13-45 14;  4562-4565. 

Debate  in  the  Senate  on  Senate  resolution  366,  offered  by  Mr.  Cum- 
mins, requesting-  the  President  to  transmit  certain  informa- 
tion secured  by  the  board  of  experts  relative  to  various 
commodities  named  in  the  bill  for  reciprocity  with  Canada. 
Feb.  23,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  Jfi,  no.  62  (cun^ent 
fiU):  3346-3347. 

Debate  in  the  Senate  on  the  bill  (H.  R.  32216)  "To  promote  recipro- 
cal trade  relations  with  the  Dominion  of  Canada  and  for  other  pur- 
poses."'    Feb.  24,  28;  Mar.  2,  4,  10,  1911. 

Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  40,  nos.  63,  67, 
69,  71,  74  {current  file):  3J^7-3lfi8;  37Jfi-3755;  3793; 
3795-3798;  3806-3811;  3905-3997;  4005-4008;  4028- 
Jfi32;  J,Ji05-4418;  1^573-4577. 

Barclay,  Charles  F.     Canadian  reciprocity.     Speech  in  the  House  of 
Representatives,  Feb.  14-,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  srss.,  r.  1,6,  no.  60  {c>irr<)d 
■file):  3188-3190. 
Opposed. 

Bennet,  William  S.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.    Speech  in  th(<  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  13,  1911. 
Congressional  recf/rd,  61st  Cong.  3d  sesx.,  r.  1,6,  no.  66  {current 
file):  3661-3667. 

Opposed. 

21 


22  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

Beveridge,  Albert  J.     Canadian  reciprocity.     Speech  in  the  Senate, 
Feb.  9,  1911. 

Congressional  reco?'d,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4-6,  no.  49  {current 

file):  mO-23U- 
Favorable. 

Borland,    William  P.     Reciprocity    with   Canada.     Speech   in   the 
Honse  of  Representatives,  Feb.  li,  1011. 
Congi'essional  record.,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  46,  no.  56  {current 
file):  2850-2852. 
Favorable. 

Broussard,  James  F.     Reciprocity   with   Canada.     Speech   in  the 
House  of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess. ,  v.  46,  no.  53  {current 
file):  2632-2635. 
Opposed. 

Burke,  James  Francis.     Reciprocity   with   Canada.     Speech  in  the 
House  of  Representatives,  Feb.  11,  1911. ' 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  IfB-i  '>^o.  53  {current 
file):  2621-2622. 
Favorable. 

Butler,  Thomas  S.     Canadian  reciprocity.     Speech  in  the  House  of 
Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Cyngressional  record,  61si  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  46,  no.  57  {current 
file):  2925-2927. 
Favorable. 

Calderhead,  Willitim  A.     Reciprocity  with   Canada.     Remarks  in 
the  House  of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess. ^v.  46,  no.  53  {currejit 
file):  2647. 
Opposed. 

Clark,  Champ.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House  of 
Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  ^6\  no.  53  {current 
file):  2622-2627. 
Favorable. 

Crawford,  Coe  I.     Tariff  and  reciprocity.     Remarks  in  the  Senate, 
Feb.  27,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong'.  3d  sess.,  v.  46,  no.  69  {current 
file):  4028-4032. 
Opposed. 


EECIPEOCITY   WITH    CANADA  23 

Cullop,  William  A.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record^  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4-6,  no.  67  {current 
file):  3757-3759. 
Favorable. 

Dalzell,  John.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House  of 
Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record.,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  46,  no.  5^.  {current 
file):  2657-2661. 
Opposed. 

Davidson,  James  H.     Canadian  reciprocity.     Speech  in  the  House  of 
Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congress io7ial  7'ecord,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  46,  no.  63{curre7it 
file):  3430-3434.. 
Opposed. 

Dawson,  Albert  F.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  6 Id  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4^,  no.  53  {cur- 
rent file):  2636-3637. 
Opposed. 

Dickinson,  Clement  C.     Canadian  reciprocity.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4^i  t^o.  57  {cur- 
rent file):  29U-2942. 
Favoral^le. 

Fairchild,  George  \V.     Canadian  reciprocity'.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  46,  no.  55  {cur- 
rent fih):  2730. 
Opposed. 

Focht,  Benjamin  K.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Repn^scntatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,   c.  1^6,  no.  5 4  {cur- 
rent file):  2663-2664. 
Ojiposcd. 

Fordney,    Jo.scph   W.     Rociprocity    with   Canada.     Speech    in    the 
House  of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  lull. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong,  3d  sees.,  v.  46i  no.  57  {cur- 
rent file):  2921-2925. 
Opposed. 


24  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

Foss,  Eugene  N.     Tariff  reduction  and  reciprocity.     Speech  in  the 
House  of  Representatives,  May  21,  1910. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  2(1  sess.,  v.  4^,  pt.  6:  6695- 
6699.  Jll.R5,v.45,pt.6 

Gaines,  .Joseph  H.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  13,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4-6,  no.  5"2  {cur- 
rentfile):  2557-2563. 
Opposed. 

Gardner,  Augustus   P.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in'  the 
House  of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  ^6,  no.  55  {cur- 
rejitjile):  2737-27^1. 

Opposed.     Reprinted  in  Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess., 
V.  46,  no.  63  (current  file),  pp.  3413-3418. 

Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House  of  Repre- 
sentatives, Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4-6 -,  no.  56  {cur- 
rent file):  2858. 

Relating  to  the  right  of  Congress  to  amend  a  reciprocity  con- 
vention. 

Gillespie,   Oscar   W.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech    in  the 
House  of  Representatives,  Feb,  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  1^.6,  no.  61  [cur- 
rent file):  3265-3269. 
Favorable. 

Good,   James  W.     Canadian  reciprocity.     Speech  in  the  House  of 
Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  J^B,  no.  55  {current 
file):  27 3 1-27 3 }^. 
Opposed. 

Goulden,  Joseph  A.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 

Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  1^.6,  no.  53  {current 
file):  2635-2636. 
Favorable. 

Graham,  James  M.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.^  v.  ^.6,  no.  63  {current 
file):  3437-34.38. 
Favorable. 


RECIPROCITY  WITH   CANADA  25 

Grant,  John  G.     ReciprociU'  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  Hou.se  of 
Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record.,  Gist  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4^,  no.  53  {cuiTent 
file):  'B6IiJ5-2eit,6. 
Opposed. 

Griest,  William  W.     Canadian  reciprocity.     Speech  in  the  Hou.se  of 
Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911, 
Congressional  record^  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  r.  ^6',  no.  o4-  {curi'ent 
file):  366/^.-3665. 
Favorable. 

Gronna,  Asle  J.     Reciprocity^  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  Senate 
Feb.  28,  1911. 
Congressional  record.,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4^6,  no.  67  {cu7Tent 
file):  3806-3811. 
Opposed. 

Guernsey,  Frank  E.     Canadian  reciprocity.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4.6,  no.  57  {current 
file):  3942-2944. 
Opposed. 

[Reciprocity  with  Canada.]     Speech  in  the  House  of  Repre- 
sentatives, Mar.  2,  1911. 
Conq7'essional  recoi'd,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  46,  no.  70  {current 
file):  4175. 
Opposed. 

Hamilton,   Edward  L.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speecli  in  the 
llou.se  of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  rec(/rd,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  46,  no.  60  {current 
file):  3187-3188. 
rypposed. 

Hanna,  Louis   H,     Canadian   reciprocity.     Speech   in   the   House  of 
Representatives,  Fel).  14,  I'.tli. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  46,  no.  59  {current 
file):  3085-3092. 
Opposed. 

Harrison,   Francis  !>.      Reciprocity   with   Canada.      Si)oc(h    in    the 
IIou.'!iC  of  Representatives,  Feb.  IH,  litl  1. 
CongreHsUmal  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  46 •,  no.  52  {current 
file):  2564-2566. 
Favorable. 


26  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

Haugen,  Gilbert  N.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.    Speech  in  the  House 

of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 

Congressional  record^  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  46",  no.  69  {current 

file):  J^002-J^00^■^ 
Opposed. 

Hill,  Ebenezer  J.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  13,  1911. 
Congressional  record.,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4-6,  no.  52  {current 
file):  25J^9-^557. 
Favorable. 

Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House  of  Repre- 
sentatives, Feb.  13,  1911. 

Congressional  7'ecord,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess..,  v.  J4.6.,  no.  73  {current 
file):  J^562-I,565. 
Favorable. 

Hughes,  Dudley  M.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.    Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record.,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess. ,  v.  Ji.6.,  no.  53  {current 
file):  26U-2645. 
Favorable. 

Humphrey,  William  E.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the 
House  of  Representatives,  Feb.  14, 1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  Jfi,  no.  62  {current 
file):  3332-333  1^. 
Opposed. 

Keifer,  Joseph  Warren.     Canadian  reciprocity.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Conqressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  1^6,  no.  57  {current 
file):  2934-2938. 
Opposed. 

Kendall,  Nathan  E.    Reciprocity  with  Canada.    Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  13,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess. ,  v.  4-6,  no.  52  {current 
file):  2571-2572. 
Opposed. 

Kennedy,  James.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  46,  no.  55  {current 
file):  2734-2735. 
Opposed. 


RECIPROCITY   WITH   CANADA  27 

Knapp,  Charles  L.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 

Congressional  record^  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  46,  no.  Blf.  {curi'ent 
file):  2666-'2669. 
Opposed. 

Kopp,  Arthur  W.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record.^  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  Jf6,  no.  5 If.  {anient 
file):  2671-2672. 
Opposed. 

Kiistermann,  Gustav.     Canadian  reciprocity.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4^,  no.  54-  {cmrent 
file):  2670-2671. 
Favorable. 

Langley,  John  W.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congi^essional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  46,  no.  72  [cim^ent 
file):  4513-4^514. 
Opposed. 

Lindbergh,  Charles  A.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech   in  the 
House  of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4^-,  ''^o-  53  (current 
file):  2637-2639. 
Opposed. 

Longworth,  Nicholas,     Reciprocity    with   Canada.     Speech    in   the 
House  of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess. ,  v.  4^-,  '*^'^>'  53  {current 
file):  2627-2629. 

Favorable. 

Lowden,  Frank  O.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Roprcsentiitives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 

Congress', onal  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  r.  46,  no.  64  {current 
file):  2672-2073. 
Opposed. 

McCall,  Saniu(>l  W .     Kcciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  11,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4^j,  no.  50  {current 
file):  2483-2485. 
Favorable. 


28  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

McCall,    Samuel   W.     Reciprocity   with    Canada.     Speech    in    the 
House  of  Representatives,  Feb,  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record^  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  ^6?,  7W.  57  {current 
file):  2929-2931. 
Favorable. 

McCumber,  Porter  J.     Trade  agreement  with  Canada.     Speech  in 
the  Senate,  Feb.  25,  1911. 

Congressional  record.^  61st  Cong.  3d  sess..,  v.  4^,  no.  67  (current 
file):  371^0-3755. 
Opposed. 

McKinley,  William  B.     Canadian  reciprocity.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record.,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  ^,  7W.  60  (current 
file):  3190-3192. 

Text  of  address  of  President  Taft  at  joint  session  of  47th  General 
assembly  of  Illinois,  Springfield,  Feb.  11,  1911,  and  of  open 
letter  of  James  Wilson,  Secretary  of  agriculture,  to  Legislative 
committee  ot  National  grange,  dated  Feb.  9,  1911.  Mr.  Mc- 
Kinley's  remarks  are  merely  introductory. 

McMorran,  Henry.     Canadian  reciprocity.     Speech  in  the  House  of 
Representatives,  Feb.  13,  1911. 
Congressional  recoi^d.,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4^,  no.  68  (current 
file):  3911-3913. 

Opposed.  Reprinted  in  Congressional  Record,  Gist  Cong.  3d 
sess.,  v.  46,  no.  75  (current  file),  pp.  4661-4664.  Appended  is 
a  reprint  of  the  report  of  the  minority  members  of  the  Com- 
mittee on  ways  and  means  on  the  bill  (H.  R.  32216)  for  reci- 
procity with  Canada. 

Maguire,  John  A.     Canadian  reciprocity.     Speech  in  the  House  of 
Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4-6,  no.  6It.  (current 
file):  3541^-3547. 
Favorable. 

Malby,  George  R.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Co7ig.  3d  sess.,  v.  46,  no.  59  (current 
file):  3053-3057. 
Opposed. 

Mann,  James  R.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House  of 
Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  46,  no.  53  (current 
file):  2631-2632. 
Favorable. 


EECIPROCITY   WITH   CANADA  29 

Martin,  Eben  W.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  13,  1911. 
Congressional  recm'd,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.^  v.  j^6,  no.  52  {cur7'ent 
jlle):  2569-2570. 
Opposed. 

Mondell,  Frank  W.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  11,  1911. 
Congressional  record.^  61st  Cong.  3d  sess. ,  v.  I^B.,  no.  51).  {current 
file):  2661-2662. 
Opposed. 

Moore,  Joseph  Hampton.     Reciprocity  and  free  trade.     Speech  in 
the  House  of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record.,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  ^^,  no.  59  {current 
file):  30U-30J^8. 
Opposed. 

Norris,  George  W.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  11,  1911. 
Congressional  record.,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  JiB,  no.  60  {current 
file)  3181^-3187. 
Opposed. 

Palmer,  Alexander  Mitchell.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in 
the  House  of  Representatives,  Feb.  13,  1911. 
Congressional  recwd,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4-^,  no.  52  {current 
file):  2566-2569. 
Favorable. 

Peters,  Andrew  J.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  11,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  ^6,  no.  57  {cur- 
rent fie):  2938-29U. 
Favorable. 

Pickett,  Charles  E.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House 
(jf  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  scss.,  r.  J^O,  no.  02  {cur- 
rent file):  3327-3332. 
Opposed. 

Poindexter,  Miles.     Canadian  reciprocity.     Speech  in  the  House  of 
Iteprcsentatives,  Feb.  11,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61xt  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  ^6,  no.  62  {cw- 

rentfile):  3334.. 

Favoraljle,  with  reservations. 


30  LIBEARY   OF   CONGRESS 

Pujo,  Arsene  P.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House  of 
Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1011. 
Congressional  record^  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.^  v.  J^6,  no.  53  {cur- 

rentfile):  26^-26 U- 
Opposed. 

Richardson,   William.     Reciprocity   with  Canada.     Speech  in  the 
House  of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record.^  61st  Cong.  3d  sess. ,  v.  Jf.6,  no.  56  {cur- 
rent fJe):  2852-2854. 
Favorable. 

Sherwood,  Isaac  R.     Canadian  reciprocity.     Speech  in  the  House  of 
Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4.6,  no.  61  {current 
file):  3274-3276. 

Favorable,  with  reservations. 

Simmons,  Furnifold  M.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the 
Senate,  Mar.  2,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  46,  no.  74  {current 
file):  4573-4577. 
Opposed. 

Smith,  Ellison  D.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  Senate, 
Feb.  27,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  46,  no.  69  {current 
file):  3995-3997. 
Favorable. 

Steenerson,  Halvor.    Agriculture  appropriation  bill — Canadian  reci- 
procity.   Speech  in  the  House  of  Representatives,  Feb.  11, 
1911. " 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4^-,  1^0.  52  {current 
file):  2516-2521. 
Opposed. 

Sterling,  John  A.     Canadian  reciprocity.     Speech  in  the  House  of 
Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 

Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4^}  '^^o.  59  {current 
file):  3073-3075. 
Opposed. 

Sulzer,  William.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  46,  no.  55  {cur- 
rent file):  2736. 
Favorable. 


RECIPROCITY  WITH   CANADA  31 

Swasey,  John  P.     Canadian  reciprocity.     Speech  in  the  House  of 
Representatives,  Feb.  19,  1911. 

Congressional  record^  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4^,  no.  63  {cur- 
rent fie):  3U5-3U9' 
Opposed. 

Thomas,  Charles  R.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Speech  in  the  House 
of  Representatives,  Feb.  13,  1911. 
Congressional  record.,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4^^,  no.  63  {cu?'- 
rentfile):  3393-3399. 
Favorable. 

Underwood,  Oscar  W.     Speech  in  the  House  of  Representatives, 
Feb.  14, 1911,  on  the  bill  (H.  R.  32216)  to  permit  reciprocal 
trade  relations  with  the  Dominion  of  Canada. 
Congressional  record.^  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  46,  no.  53  {cur- 
rent Jile):  2619-2621. 
Favorable. 

Volstead,   Andrew  J.     Reciprocity   with   Canada.     Speech   in   the 
House  of  Representatives,  Feb.  14,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  4^^  "^^o.  53  {cur- 
rent file):  2639-2641. 
Opposed. 

Young,  Lafayette.     The  proposed  American  donation  to  Canada. 
Speech  in  the  Senate,  Feb.  28,  1911. 
Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  46,  no.  69  {current 
file):  4O05-4008. 
Opposed. 


UNITED  STATES   DOCUMENTS 

Bachelder,  Nahum  Josiah.  Reciprocity  with  Canada.  Letter. of 
chairman  Legislative  committee,  National  grange,  Con- 
cord, N.  H.,  to  Hon.  James  Wilson,  Secretary  of  agricul- 
ture, regarding  reciprocity  with  Canada. 
[Washmgto)i:  Govt,  prhit.  off.,  1911.]  '2  pp.  8°.  {Gist 
Cong.  3d  sess.  Senate.  Doc.  828.) 
Letter  dated  Feb.  13,  1911. 

Barker,  Wharton.     Our  Canadian  relations. 

[Washington:    Govt,  print,  off.,   1911.']     18pp.     8°.     (61st 
Cong.  3d  sess.     House.     Doc.  lit  17.) 
Ordered  to  be  printed  Mar.  3,  1911. 

Letter  to  James  A.  Garfield,  House  of  Representatives,  dated 
Apr.  27,  1880;  note  to  William  M.  Evarts,  U.  S.  Senate,  dated 
Jan.  5,  1886,  with  Memorandum  concerning  Canada;  letter  to 
Justin  S.  Morrill,  chairman  Finance  committee,  U.  S.  Senate, 
dated  Nov.  28,  1887,  with  INIemorandum  upon  (1)  the  national 
revenues  and  their  surplus;  (2)  trade  relations  of  the  United 
States  and  Canada. 
11-35270  HF1732.C2B32 

Carter,  Thomas  H.,  comp.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Papers  in  the 
consideration  of  bill  (H.  R.  32216)  relating  to  reciprocity 
with  Canada. 
\_Wa^hington:    Govt.  p>Tint.  off.,  1911.]    55  p>p.     8°.     {61st 
Cong.  3d  sess.     Senate.     Doc.  862.) 

Also  printed  in  Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess..  Mar.  4, 
1911,  v.  46,  no.  71  (current  file),  pp.  4405-4418. 

Contents. — H.  R.  32216,  61st  Congress,  3d  session.  An  act  to 
promote  reciprocal  trade  relations  with  the  Dominion  of  Can- 
ada, and  for  other  purposes;  [Text]  (pp.  1-10);  [Analysis, 
comment  and  statistics]  (pp.  10-31);  Address  of  President 
Taft  at  the  National  corn  exposition,  Columbus,  Ohio,  Feb.  10, 
1911  (pp.  31-.36);  Address  of  President  Taft  at  the  joint  session 
of  the  47th  General  assembly  of  Illinois  at  Springfield,  Feb.  11, 
1911  (pp.  36-41);  Open  letter  [from  James  Wilson,  Secretary 
of  agriculture]  to  the  Legislative  committee.  National  grange, 
Concord,  N.  H.,  Feb.  9,  1911  (pp.  42-46);  Commercial  rela- 
tions of  the  United  States  with  Canada,  by  John  Ball  Osborne, 
chief.  Bureau  of  trade  relations.  Department  of  state  (pp.  47-55). 

Hri732.C2C4 
32 


RECIPEOCTTY   WITH   CANADA  33 

Daniel,  John  Wcrwick.  The  lumber  schedule.  Paper  entitled 
''Data  on  the  lumljer  schedule;"  also  a  sworn  statement  of 
the  diflerence  in  the  wage  scale  of  the  United  States  and 
Canada,  etc. 
[  Washing f 071 :  Govt,  print,  of.,  1909.]  8  pj).  8°.  {61st 
Cong.  1st  sess.     Senate.     Doc.  111.) 

Presented  by  Mr.  Daniel.     Ordered  printed,  June  21, 1909.     Paper 
by  L.  W.  Whitehead. 

9-35631  HF265 1  .L803D2 

Knox,  Philander  Chase.     Reciprocity  with  Canada. 

[Washington:    Go^^t.    print,    of.,  1911.]     9  pp.     8°.     {61st 
Cong.  3d  sess.     House.     Doc.  14-18.) 
Ordered  to  be  printed  Mar.  3,  1911. 

Address  before  the  Chicago  association  of  commerce,  Feb.  15, 1911. 
11-35269  HF1732.C2K7 

Moline  daily  dispatch,  Mbline,  III.     Canadian  reciprocity.     Arti- 
cle published  in  the  Moline  daily  dispatch  of  Feb.  13, 1911, 
relative  to  reciprocity  with  ('anada. 
[Washington:    Govt,  print,    off.,    1911.]     6  i^p.     8°.     {61st 
Cong.  3d  sess.     Senate.     Doc.  8Jf£. ) 

Presented  by  INIr.  duPont.    Ordered  printed  Feb.  28,  1911. 

11-35256  HF1732.C2M7 

U.  S.  38th  Cmigress,  1863-1865.  Extracts  from  Congressional  debates 
on  the  reciprocity  treat}'  of  185-1  with  Canada,  together 
with  message  of  the  President  transmitting  the  treat\'  to 
Congress. 
Washington:  Govt,  print,  off.,  1911.  185  j^P-  ^°-  {'Slst 
Cong.  3d  ses-s.     House.     Doc.  1350.) 

Presented  by  Mr.  Gaines.  Ordered  printed  Feb.  2,  1911. 
Contexts. — Proceedings  preliminary  to  the  reciprocity  treaty. — 
The  treaty. — The  legislation  to  carry  out  the  treaty. — Extension 
of  treaty  to  Newfoundland. — Workings  of  the  treaty.— The 
legislation  to  terminate  the  treaty. — Debate  in  the  House, 
[May  18-May  26,  ]8()4]. — Further  proceedings  in  the  House, 
[Dec.  13,  1864].— I'roceedings  in  the  Senate,  [Dec.  19,  1864- 
Jan.  12,  1865]. — House  concurs  in  Senate  amendments. — Ap- 
proved by  President. 

11-35151  HF1732.C2A4     1854 

Congress.  JTovse.  Committee  on  ways  and  meanK.  Reci- 
procity with  Canada.  Hearings  before  the  Conmiittee  on 
ways  and  means  of  the  House  of  representatives,  filst 
Congress,  3d  sessioti.  on  II.  K.  32216,  February  2,  4,  G,  7, 
8,  and  9,  1911. 
Washington :  Gorf.  print.  off\,  1911.  3.'f'2  j)p.  8°. 
S.  E.  Payne,  chairman. 

11-35190  Hri732.C2A4     1911b 


34  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

Includes  extended  statements  by  the  following:  Augustus  P. 
Gardner,  Representative  from  Massachusetts  (pp.  3-6) ;  Arthur 
L.  Millett  (pp.  6-13);  William  H.  Thomas  (pp.  16-28); 
Thomas  J.  Carroll  (pp.  34-55);  Charles  F.  Wonson  (pp.  58-66); 
Leonard  A.  Treat  (pp.  66-73) ;  Isaac  Patch,  mayor  of  G  loucester, 
Mass.  (pp.  73-80);  L.  B.  Hanna,  Representative  from  North 
Dakota,  (pp.  81-85);  Edward  Hines,  National  lumber  manu- 
facturers' association  (pp.  85-103;  275-288);  George  R.  Malby, 
Representative  from  New  York  (pp.  104-119) ;  Bruno  E.  Fink 
(pp.  119-135);  J.  R.  Mauff,  American  society  of  equity  (pp. 
135-150);  Francis  M.  Hugo  (pp.  154-171);  Alfred  S.  Hall 
(pp.  175-185);  William  E.  Humphrey,  Representative  from 
Washington  (pp.  202-222);  R.  P.  Grant  (pp.  222-228);  Aaron 
Jones,  National  grange  (pp.  237-242);  John  Norria  (pp.  242- 
265);  D.  E.  Skinner  (pp.  292-307). 

U.  S.      Congress.      House.      Committee  on   ivays  and  Tneans.      Reci- 
procity with  Canada.      Report.      <To  accompany  H.  R. 
32216. > 
{Washington:  Govt. print. off. .,1911. \     6pp.    8°.     {61st  Cong. 
Sdsess.     Rouse.     RejA.  2150.) 

Submitted  by  Mr.  McCall.     Committed  to  the  Committee  of  the 
whole  house  on  the  state  of  the  Union,  and  ordered  printed, 
Feb.  11,  1911. 
11-35190  HF1732.C2A4     1911a 

Senate.      Committee   on  finance.     Reciprocity    with    Canada. 

Compilation  of  documents  relating  to  the  proposed  agree- 
ment of  1911,  and  to  the  treaty  of  1854  and  its  subsequent 
operation.     Feb.  18,  1911. 
Washington:  Govt,  print,  off.,  1911.     [84.6]  pp.     8°. 

Contents. — Special  message  of  President  Taft,  Jan.  26,  1911,  with 
correspondence,  etc. — H.  R.  32216,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.  An  act 
to  promote  reciprocal  trade  relations  with  the  Dominion  of 
Canada,  and  for  other  purposes.  — Hearings  and  reports  on  the 
bill,  Committee  on  ways  and  means,  Feb.  2-15,  1911. — Reci- 
procity treaty  as  to  fisheries,  duties,  and  navigation,  British 
North  America,  June  5,  1854. — 33d  Cong.  1st  sess.  Senate. 
Report  of  Committee  on  foreign  relations,  July  11,  1854.  -  37th 
Cong.  2d  sess.  House  report  no.  22.  Reciprocity  treaty  with 
Great  Britain,  report  of  Committee  on  commerce,  Feb.  5, 1862. — 
38th  Cong.  1st  sess.  House  ex.  doc.  no.  32.  Reciprocity  treaty, 
letter  from  the  Secretary  of  the  Treasury,  Feb.  1,  1864. — 38th 
Cong.  Ist  sess.  House  report  no.  39.  Reciprocity  treaty,  report 
of  Committee  on  commerce,  Apr.  1,  1864. — 39th  Cong.  1st  sess. 
House  ex.  doc.  no.  128.  Commercial  relations  with  British 
America,  letter  from  the  Secretary  of  the  Treasury,  June  14, 
1886. — 39th  Cong.  2d  sess.  Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  30.  Message 
from  the  President,  Feb.  19,  1867,  transmitting  report  of  Secre- 
tary Seward,  and  papers  to  which  it  refers. 


RECIPROCITY   WITH   CANADA  35 

U.  S.     Senate.      Committee  on  finance.     Reciprocity   with    Canada. 
Hearings  before  the  Committee  on  finance  of  the  United 
States  Senate  on  H.  R.  32216:  An  act  to  promote  reciprocal 
trade  relations  with  the  Dominion  of  Canada  and  for  other 
purposes. 
Washington:    Govt,  print,    off.,   1911.     332  pp.     8°.     {61st 
Cong.  3d.  sess.  Senate.  Doc.  834-.) 
Presented  by  Mr.  Smoot. 
Feb.  24,  1911.— Ordered  to  be  printed. 

Includes  extended  statements  by  the  following:  John  Strange 
(pp.  3-15,  323-325);  Edward  Hines,  National  lumber  manu- 
facturers' association  (pp.  15-31);  Charles  M.  Gardner,  Massa- 
chusetts state  grange  (pp.  45-53);  Augustus  P.  Gardner, 
Representative  from  Massachusetts  (pp.  64-78);  Elihu  Root, 
Senator  from  New  York  (pp.  78-82);  N.  P.  Hull,  Michigan 
state  grange  (pp.  127-130;  254-266);  John  P.  Swasey,  Repre- 
sentative from  Maine  (pp.  152-155);  Arthur  C  Hastings, 
American  paper  and  pulp  association  (pp.  156-216;  285-287); 
John  Norris,  American  newspaper  publishers'  association 
(pp.  217-247);  Elon  R.  Brown  (pp.  272-285);  Chester  W. 
Lyman,  International  paper  company  (pp.  295-320). 
Reprint  of  a  pamphlet  by  William  Whitman,  entitled  "Objec- 
tions to  reciprocity  on  constitutional  and  practical  grounds," 
(Boston,  1904):  pp.  90-105. 

HF1732.C2A4     1911d 

Dept.  ofi agriculture.    Reciprocity  with  Canada.    Letter  of  the 

Secretary  of  agriculture  [James  Wilson]  to  the  Legislative 
committee,  National  grange,  Concord,  N.  H.,  in  reference 
to  the  proposed  Canadian  reciprocity  treaty. 
[Washington:   Govt,  print,  off.,  191 1.]    6  pp.  8°.     {61st  Cmig. 
3d  sess.     Senate.     Doc.  829.) 
Letter  dated  Feb.  9,  1911. 

Also  printed  in  Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.,  3d  sess.,  v.  46, 
no.  52,  (current  file),  pp.  2532-2533,  and  in  no.  60  (current  file), 
pp.  3191-3192. 

Dept.  of  state.     Tariff  negotiations  between  the  United  States 

and  foreign  governments.  Message  from  the  President  of 
the  United  States,  transmitting  through  the  Secretary  of 
state  and  the  Secretar}'  of  the  Treasury,  reports  relative  to 
recent  tarill  negotiations  between  the  government  of  the 
United  States  and  foreign  governments  made  necessary  by 
the  Tariff  act  of  August  5,  1!»09. 
Washington:  Govt. 2>rlnt.<ff'., 1910.  lhGpi>.8'^.  {61st  Cong. 
2d  sess.     House.     Doc.  956.) 

Referred  to  Committee  on   ways  and   means;   ordered    ])rinted 

June  9,  1910. 
"Canada":    p.  13;    "Canadian   t;iriff    concessions    [correspond- 
ence]" :  pp.  141-149. 

10-36903  HF1731.A5     1910 


36  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

TJ.  S.     Laws,  statutes,  etc.    An  act  to  promote  reciprocal  trade  rela- 
tions with  the  Dominion  of  Canada,  and  for  other  purposes. 
[Washington:    Govt. 2:)rint.  off.,  1911.]     34, pjj.  4-°. 

At  head  of  title:  61st  Congress,  3d  session.     H.  R.  32216.     In  the 
Senate  of  the  United  States.     Feb.  15,  1911.     Read  twice  and 
referred  to  the  Committee  on  finance. 
Text  of  the  bill  as  passed  by  the  House  of  Representatives,  Feb.  14. 

President  (Ta ft).     Canadian  reciprocity.     Special  message  of 

the  President  of  the  United  States  transmitted  to  the  two 
houses  of  Congress  January  2H,  1911.  Correspondence 
embodying  an  agreement  between  the  Department  of  state 
and  the  Canadian  government  in  regard  to  reciprocal  tariff 
legislation.  Also  statistical  data  to  show  the  effect  of  the 
above  agreement  upon  the  commerce  and  revenues  of  the 
United  States  and  the  Dominion  of  Canada. 

Washington:    Govt,  print.  off\,  1911.     nr,  {2),75 pp.     Tables. 

.    8°.     {Gist  Cong.  3d  sess.     Senate.     Doc.  787.) 

Read,  referred  to  the  Committee  on  finance,  and  ordered  printed, 

Jan.  26,  1911. 
Also  printed  in  Congressional  record,  61st  Cong.  3d  sess.,  v.  46, 

no.  35  (current  file),  pp.  1516-1518,  1559-1564. 

11-35123  Hri732.C2A4     1911 

Tariff  hoard.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Message  from  the 

President  of  the  United  States  transmitting  in  response  to 

Senate  resolution  of  February  23,  1911,  a  report  from  the 

Tariff  board  relative  to  various  commodities  named  in  the 

proposed  Canadian  reciprocity  measure.     Mar.  1,  1911. 

Washington:    Govt,  print,   of.,  1911.      132  pp.     8°.      (61st 

Cong.  3d  sess.     Senate.     Doc.  8^9.) 

Hri732.C2A4     1911f 


CANADIAN    AND    BRITISH    DOCUMENTS 

Canada.  Dept.  of  finance.  Return:  Trade  relations  with  United 
States;  memorandum  on  proposed  changes  in  the  Canadian 
customs  tariff,  showing  (1)  Statement  of  articles  imported 
from  all  countries  on  which  reductions  are  proposed ;  (2) 
Statement  of  articles  entered  under  tariff  item  no.  711;  (8) 
Statement  of  articles  imported  from  the  United  States  on 
which  reductions  are  proposed. 
[Ottawa,  1910.]    6  pp.     ^°. 

(7n  Canada.  Parliament,  1910.  Sessional  paper,  no.  lOi.  v.  44, 
pt.  6.)  J103.Ll,v.44,pt.6 

Tariff  relations  between  the  United  States  and  the  Dominion 

of  Canada.     Correspondence  respecting  negotiations,  [Feb. 
18- Apr.  7],  1910. 
[Ottaica,  1910.]     8  pp.     ^°. 

{In  Canada.     Parliament,  1910.     Sessional  paper,  no.  lOj.     v.  44, 

pt.  6.) 
Presented  Apr.  27,  1910,  by  W.  S.  Fielding,  Minister  of  finance. 

Jl03.Ll,v.44,pt.6 

Tariff  i-elations  between  the  United  States  and  the  Dominion 

of  Canada.     Correspondence  and  statements,  1911. 
Ottawa:  Govt,  print,  hureau.,  1911.     70  pp.     8°. 

Correspondence  between  W.  S.  Fielding  and  Wni.  Patorson,  of 
Canada,  and  P.  C.  Knox,  Secretary  of  state  of  the  United  States. 

HF1732.C2A4     1911g 

Parliament.    Iloum  of  Comnionx.     [Debate  on]  tariff  nego- 
tiations with  the  United  States.     Mar.  30,  1910. 

{In  lis  Official  report  of  the  debates,  11th  Parliament,  2d  .session, 
V.  96.     Ottawa,  1910.     4°.     cols.  5942-(500:?. ) 

Principal  speakers:  .lohii  A.  Ciirric,  William  S.  Ficldintr,  Sir 
Wilfrid  I.auri.r,  William  K.  Maclean.  J103.K2,v.96 

|I)ci)jite  oil]  trade  relations  with  the  United  States.     May  iJ, 

1910. 

{In  iln  Official  report  of  the  debates,  11th  Parliament,  2d  scssioi), 
V.  97.     Ottawa,  1910.     4°.     cols.  8742-8763.) 

J103.K2,v.97 

37 


ll'4H22. 


38  LIBKARY   OF    CONGRESS 

Canada.     Parliament.     House  of  Commons.     [Debate  on]  reciprocal 
trade  with  the  United  States.     Jan.  26-Mar.  14,  1911. 

{In  its  Official  report  of  the  debates,  11th  Parliataent,  3d  session; 

unrev.  ed.,  v.  44,  nos.  32,  42,  45-47,  50-52,  55,  56,  59-61,  64. 

[Ottawa,  1911.]     4°.     cols.   2494-2556;    3352-3412;    3605-3674; 

3685-3740;  3744-3746;  3758-3844;  4030-4071;  4073-4118;  4131- 

4190;  4196-4280;  4472-4552;   4561-4563;   4572-4654;  4835-4918; 

4926-5019;  5030-5132;  5364-5392.) 

Principal  speakers: 
Ames,  Herbert  B.:  Feb.  22,  no.  51:  4163-4190. 
Armstrong,  Joseph  E.:  Feb.  16,  no.  47:  3815-3844. 
Blain,   Richard:    Feb.  15,  no.    46:    3687-3698;    Feb.  23,  no.  52: 

4249-4265. 
Borden,  Robert  L.:   Jan.  26,  no.  32:  2551-2556;  Feb.  9,  no.  42: 

3362-3384;  Mar.  8,  no.  60:  4926-4941. 
Burrell,  Martin:  Feb.  14,  no.  45:  3654-3674. 
Carvell,  Frank  B.:  Mar.  2,  no.  56:  4586-4625. 
Clark,  Michael:  Feb.  23,  no.  52:  4225-4251. 
Currie,  John  A. :  Mar.  7,  no.  59:  4865-4905. 
s    Fielding,  William  S.:  Jan.  26,  no.  32:  2494-2532;  Feb.  9,  no.  42: 

3357-3361;  Mar.  8,  no.  60:  4941-4948. 
Fisher,  Sydney:  Feb.  28,  no.  55:  4497-4552. 
Foster,  George  E.:  Feb.  9,  no.  42:    3395-3412;  Feb.  14,  no.  45: 

3605-3637;  Mar.  8,  no.  60:  4948-4952. 
German,  William  M. :  Mar.  2,  no.  56:  4572-4586. 
Goodeve,  Arthur  S.:  Mar.  9,  no.  61:  5067-5111. 
Guthrie,  Hugh:  Feb.  15,  no.  46:  3705-3740. 
Harris,  Lloyd:  Mar.  8,  no.  60:  4973-5001. 
Kyte,  George  W. :  Feb.  21,  no.  50:  4035-4058. 
Laurier,  Sir  Wilfrid:  Mar.  7,  no.  59:  4835-4865. 
Lemieux,  Rodolphe:  Feb.  21,  no.  50:  4083-4118. 
Lennox,  Haughton:  Feb.  16,  no.  47:  3758-3786. 
McKenzie,  Donald  D.:  Mar.  9,  no.  61:  5111-5132;  Mar.  14,  no. 

64:  5364-5392. 
Middlebro,  William  S.:  Mar.  2,  no.  56:  4625-4654. 
Miller,  Henry  H.:    Mar.  8,  no.  60:   5001-5019;    Mar.  9,  no.  61: 

5034-5067. 
Molloy,  John  P.:  Feb.  23,  no.  52:  4265-4278. 
Neely,  David  B.:  Feb.  14,  no.  45:  3638-3654. 
Paterson,  William:  Feb.  9,  no.  42:  3384-3395. 
Sifton,  Clifford:  Feb.  28,  no.  55:  4472-4497. 
Sproule,  T.  S.:  Feb.  21,  no.  50:  4059-4071,  4073-4083. 
Templeman,  William:  Mar.  7,  no.  59:  4905-4918. 
Warburton,  Alexander  B.:  Feb.  16,  no.  47:  3787-3815. 

Schedules  of  the  reciprocity  agreement:  Jan.  26,  no.  32:  2519- 
2528,  2533-2549. 

Resolution  that  it  is  expedient  to  amend  the  Customs  tariff, 

1907.     Jan.  26, 1911. 
[Ottawa,  1911.']    7  pp.     8°. 

Resolution  for  reciprocity  with  the  United  States. 


EECIPROCITY    WITH    CANADA  39 

Canada.  Farmers'  delegation^  1910.  Report  of  proceedings  in  the 
hearing  by  members  of  the  government  of  the  Farmers' 
delegation,  December  16,  1910,  with  correspondence  pre- 
liminary to  the  hearing.  Printed  by  order  of  Parliament. 
Ottawa;  Printed  hy  C.  H.  Parmelee.,  1911.  57  pp.  8°, 
{Parliament.     Sessional  paper.,  no.  113.^  A.     1911.) 

HD9044.A5     1910 

The  Delegation  of  farmers,  1910,  was  organized  under  the  Canadian 

council  of  agriculture. 
The  customs  tariff  and  reciprocity  with  the  United  States:  pp. 

38-56. 

Great  Britain.  Board  of  trade.  Canada — United  States  of  America: 
reciprocity  arrangement.  Proposed  customs  tariff  reci- 
procity arrangement  between  the  Dominion  of  Canada  and 
the  United  States  of  America.  Presented  to  both  houses  of 
Parliament.  Feb.  1911. 
London :  II.  21.  Stationery  office,  1911.  20  pp.  F°.  {Par- 
liament.    Papers  hy  command.     Gd.  5537.) 

Colonial  office.     Canada.     Papers  relating  to  a  proposed  com- 

mercial arrangement  between  Canada  and  the  United  States 
of  America.  Presented  to  both  houses  of  Parliament.  Feb. 
1911. 

London:  11.  M.  Stationery  office.,  1911.     8  pp.     F°.     {Par- 
liament.    Papers  hy  command.      Cd.  5512.) 

Legation.    U.  S.     Reports   from  His  Majesty's  ambassador 

at  Washington  respecting  a  reciprocal  tariff  arrangement 
between  Canada  and  the  United  States.     Presented  to  both 
houses  of  Parliament.     Mar.  1911. 
London:  II.  M.  Stationery  off.,  [1911].     {2),  15,  {1)  pp.   F°. 
{Gt.  Brit.      Foreign  office.      Commercial.     No.  1.) 

Parliament.     Papers  by  command.     Cd.  5523. 

James  Bryce,  ambassador.  HF1732.C2A4     191  Ih 


IIsrDEX 


rage 
Agriculture: 
See  Farmers 

Allum,  T.  C 18 

American  newspaper    publishers' 

association 35 

American  paper  and  pulp  associa- 
tion    35 

American  society  of  equity 34 

Ames,  Herbert  B 38 

ArgA'll,  John  D.  S.  Campbell,  9th 

duke  of 4 

Armstrong,  Joseph  E 38 

Ashley,  Percy  Walter  Llewellyn..  5 

Bachelder,  Nahum  Josiah 18, 32 

Barclay,  Charles  F 21 

Barker,  "Wharton 32 

Barrett,  R.  J 3 

Bellerivp,  Georges 5 

Bennet,  William  8 21 

Beveridge,  Albert  J 19,22 

Biggar,  E.  B 17 

Blain,  Richard 38 

Borden,  Robert  L 38 

Borland,  William  P 22 

Bourassa,  Henri 5 

Bourinot,  Sir  John  George 4 

Bradley,  Arthur  Granville 4 

Brigham,  K.  S 14 

Broussard,  James  F 22 

Brown,  YAon  R 35 

Bryce,  James 39 

I'urke,  James  Francis 22 

Barrel],  Martin 38 

P.iitlcr,  Thomas  R 22 

CuI.UtIuwI,  William  A  .. 22 

Canada.    CenguJi  and  skUixlics  office.  3 

De.])t.  of  agrlruUure 3 

Depl.  of  niMoms 3 

D('}>t.  of  finance 3,37 

Dejd.  of  inland  revenue. . .  3 

Depl.  of  Inbonr 3 

Depl .  of  Secretary  of  state .  4 

Depl.oftnideand  commerce  3 

J'arlianienl 37,  38 


Page 

Canada.  Census,  1901 3 

Commerce 3,32,34,36 

Commercial    union  with 

United  States 18 

Finance 3,6,36 

Forest  resources 3 

Productions 3 

Resources 3 

Statistics 3,36 

See  also  Farmers;  Investments; 
Liberal  part j' ;  Manufactur- 
ers; Nationalist  party; 
Newfoundland;  Prices; 
Railways;  Tariff;  Treaties; 
Wages 

Canada:  an  encyclopaedia 3 

Canada  club,  London 11 

Canada.    Farmers'  delegation,  1910  39 
Canadian  annual  review  of  public 

affairs 3, 5 

Canadian  (-lul),  Toronto 9 

Canadian  council  of  agriculture. . .  9,  39 
Canadian  manufacturers'  associa- 
tion    8, 13 

Canadian  Who's  who 3 

Carman,  All)ert  R 18 

Carroll,  Thomas  J 34 

Carter,  Thomas  H 32 

Carvell,  Frank  B 38 

Chamberlain,  Austen 17 

Chapleau,  J.  A 4, 5 

Chicago  a.«sociation  of  commerce. .  18,  33 

Clark,  Clianip 13,22 

Clark,  Michael 38 

Cobdeu  chib 6 

Cockl>iirn,  A.  P 4 

Collins,  Paul  V 5 

Commercial  clul),  I'roridencc,  Ji.  I.  5 
Commercial  handbook  of  Canada.  3 
Commodities  affected  by  reciproc- 
ity agreement 21 ,  36 

Fish 12,34,35 

Fruit 15 

Iron 12 

41 


42 


INDEX 


Page 
Commodities  affected  b)'  reciproc- 
ity agreement — Continued. 

Lumber 20,33,34,35 

Wheat 14 

Wood  pulp 35 

Conservative  party  of  Great  Brit- 
ain and  reciprocity 17 

Constitutionality     of     reciprocity 

treaties 35 

Cook,  Herbert  E 19 

Cost  of  living  and  reciprocity 19,  20 

See  also  Prices 

Crawford,  Coe  I 22 

Cullop,  William  A 23 

Cmnmins,  Albert  B 21 

Currie,  John  A 37,38 

Dalzell,  John 23 

Daniel,  John  Warwick 33 

Davidson,  James  H 23 

Dawson,  Albert  F 23 

Democratic  party  and  reciprocity.         15 

Dewavrin,  M.  L 3 

Dicey,  Edward 16 

Dickinson,  Clement  C 23 

Dodge,  Arthur  J 15 

Drury,  E.  C 13 

du  Pont,  Henry  A 33 

Edmonds,  W.  L 12, 16 

Egerton,  Hugh  Edward 4 

Fairchild,  George  W 23 

Farmers  of  Canada  and  reciprocity         9, 

10, 13,  39 
Farmers  of  United  States  and  reci- 
procity ...  5, 14, 17, 18, 19,  28,  32,  34,  35 
Favored-nation  clause: 

See  -Most-favored-nation  claiise 

Fenwick,  C.  B 20 

Fielding,  William  S 11,  37,  38 

Fink,  Bruno  E 34 

Fish: 

See  Commodities 

Fisher,  Sydney 38 

Focht,  Benjamin  K 23 

Fordney,  Joseph  W 23 

Forests  of  Canada: 

See  Canada;  Forest  resources 

Foss,  Eugene  N 24 

Foster,  George  E 8,9,38 

Eraser,  John  Foster 4 

Fruit: 

See  Commodities 

Gaines,  Joseph  H 24, 33 

Gardner,  Augustus  P 24, 34,  35 


Gardner,  Charles  M  . 
Garvin,  J.  L 

German,  William  M. 
Gillespie,  Oscar  W. . . 


35 

17 

38 

24 

Good,  James  W 24 

Goodeve,  Arthur  S 38 

Goulden,  Joseph  A 24 

Graham,  James  M 24 

Grant,  John  G 25 

Grant,  E.  P 34 

Great  Britain.     Board  of  trade 3, 39 

Colonial  office 39- 

Legation.     U.  S. . .  39 
Prices: 

Canada 3 

Great  Britain 14 

See  also  Cost  of  living 

Griest,  William  W 25 

Gronna,  Asle  J 12,25 

Guernsey,  Frank  E 25 

Guthrie,  Hugh 33 

Hall,  Alfreds 34 

Hamilton,  Edward  L 25 

Hanna,  Louis  B 25,  34 

Harris,  Lloyd 33 

Harrison,  Francis  B 25 

Hastings,  Arthur  C • 35 

Haugen,  Gilbert  N 26 

Haultain,  Arnold 7 

Herbert,  Bron 6 

Hildebrand,  Gerhard 15 

Hill,  Ebenezer  J 26 

Hill,  James  Jerome 6,  9, 18 

Hines,  Edward 34,  35 

Hobson,  John  Atkinson 6 

Hopkins,  John  Castell 5,  8 

Hughes,  Dudley  M 26 

Hughes,  Hugh  J 17 

Hugo,  Francis  M 34 

Hull,  N.  P 35 

Humphrey,  William  E 26,  34 

International  paper  company 35 

Investments  of  United  States  capi- 
tal in  Canada 9 

Iron: 

See  Commodities 

Jeans,  J.  Stephen 3 

Johnson,  George 3 

Johnston,  Charles 17 

Jones,  Aaron 34 

Keif er,  Joseph  Warren 26 

Kendall,  Nathan  E 26 


INDEX 


43 


Kennedy,  James 26 

Kingman,  R.  T 12 

Kingsford,  William 3 

Knapp,  Charles  L 27 

Knox,  Philander  Chase 18, 33,  37 

Kopp,  Arthur  W 27 

Kiistermann,    Gustav 27 

Kyte,  George   W 38 

Langley,  John   W 27 

Laurier,  Sir  Wilfrid 37,38 

Lawson,  W.   R 14 

Lemieux,   Rodolphe _  38 

Lennox,  Haughton __  38 

Lethbridge,  Roper_ 19 

Liberal    party    of    Canada     and 

reciprocity 6, 10 

Liberal  party  of  Great  Britain  and 

reciprocity 19 

Lindbergh,    Charles  A 27 

Longworth,  Nicholas 27 

Low,    Maurice  A 18 

Lowden,  Frank    0 27 

Lumber: 

See  Commodities 
Lumber  schedule  of  Payne  tariff 

act - 33 

Lyman,    Chester  W 35 

Lysaght,   John 12 

McArthur,   Peter 8 

McCall,  Samuel    W 27,28,34 

McCumber,    Porter  J 28 

McGrath,  P.  T 9 

McKenzie,    Donald   D 38 

McKinley,    William  B 28 

Maclean,    William   F 37 

McMorran,  Henry 28 

MacVeagh,  Wayne 14 

Maguire,  John  A 28 

Malby,  George  R 28,  34 

Mann,  D.  D 8 

Mann,  JameH  R 28 

Man II facta rers  of  Canada  and  reci- 
procity    8,10,13 

Manufacturers  of  United  States  and 

reciprocity 5 

Martin,  Kben  W L'9 

Marvin,  Thomas  O 19 

Massachnsetts  ntate  grange 35 

Mauff,  J.  R 34 

Mavor,  James ...  1 3 

Michigan  state  grange 35 

Middlebro,  William  S 38 

Miller,  Henry  H 38 


Millett,  Arthur  L 34 

IMoline  daily  dispatch,  Moline,  III.  33 

Molloy,  John  P 38 

Mond,  Sir  Alfred 16 

Mondell,  Frank  W 29 

Montagu,  Edwin  S 6 

Moore,  Joseph  Hampton 29 

Morgan,  Henry  J 4 

jMost-favored-nation  clause 13 

Munro,  J.  E.  C 4 

National  grange 18, 32,  34 

National  lumber  manufacturers'  as- 
sociation    34,  35 

Nationalist  party  of  Canada  and 

reciprocity 5 

Neely,  David  B 38 

Nesbitt,  Wallace 9 

Newfoundland 6, 33 

Norris,  George  W 29 

Norris,  John 34,35 

Osborne,  John  Ball 32 

Palmer,  Alexander  Mitchell 29 

Patch,  Isaac 34 

Paterson,  William 37,  38 

Payne,  Sereno  E 33 

Peters,  Andrew  J 29 

Pickett,  Charles  E 29 

Poindexter,  Miles 29 

Parkman,  Francis 3 

Preferential  tariff: 

See  Tariff,  Preferential 

Pujo,  Arsene  P 30 

Porritt,  Edward 6,10,20 

Railways  of  Canada  and  reciproc- 
ity    14 

Republican  party  and  reciprocity.  15 

Richardson,  William 30 

Root,  Elihu 35 

Root,  John  William G 

Rosebery,  Archibald  P.   Primrose, 

ritli  earl  of 6 

Ross,  Sir  ( Jeorge  W 8 

Russell,  T.  A 10,13 

Selke,  David  Louis 18 

Seward,  William  II 34 

Sherwood,  Isaac  R 30 

Siegfried,  Andn'- (> 

Sifton,  Clifford Ki,  17, 18,38 

Simmons,  Furnifold  M 30 

Skelton,  Oscar  Douglas 13 

Skinner,  D.   E 34 

Smart,  William 7 

Smith,  Ellison  D 30 

Smith,  Goldwin 7 


44 


INDEX 


Page 

Smoot,  Reed 35 

Sproule,  T.  S 38 

Statistics 3,18,32,36 

Steenerson,  Halvor 30 

Sterling,  John  A 30 

Strange,  John 33 

Sulzer,    William 30 

Swasey,  John  P 31,  35 

Tariff:' 

Canada .  1, 6,  8, 9, 10, 13,  35,  37,  38, 39 

Tariff  commission,  London 7, 18 

Tariff,  Preferential 7 

Canada  and  Great  Britain 6,  7, 

11,  14, 16 

Taft,  William  Howard 17, 28, 32 

Templeman,  William 38 

Thomas,  Charles  R 31 

Thomas,  William  H 34 

Toronto.     Board  of  trade 8 

Treat,  Leonard  A 34 

Treaties  and  agreements: 

Treaty  of  1 854 9,  33,  34 

Agreement  of  1911  (text). .  36, 37,  38 

Trescher,  Erich 7 

Underwood,  Oscar  W 31 

U.  S.  Congress 21,33,34,35 

Dept.  of  agriculture 28, 32, 35 


U.  S.  Dept.  of  state 32, 34, 35, 36,  37 

Laws,  statutes,  etc 34, 36 

President  ( Pierce ) 33 

{Taft) 34,36 

Tariff  hoard 36 

Treasury  dept 34 

Commerce  with  Canada. .  32,  34,  36 
Statistics 36 

Volstead,  Andrew  J 31 

Wages: 

Canada 33 

UnitedStates '    33 

Walker,  Thomas  B 20 

Warburton,  Alexander  B 38 

Whates,  Harry  Richard 4 

Wheat: 

See  Commodities 

Whitehead,  L.  W 

Whitman,  William 

Willison,  John  Stephen 

Wilson,  James 28, 

Wouson,  CharleS^F 

Wood  pulp: 

See  Commodities 

Young,  James 

Young,  Lafayette 


33 

35 

4 

32,35 

34 


7 
10,31 


O 


SOUTHERN  BRANCH, 

UNIVERSITY  OF  CALIFORNIA, 

LIBRARY, 

^LQS  ANGELES,  C^LIf. 


z 

7164 
T2U5rc 
1911 

or  Conp:resg."Tvn7Tr^ 
sion  6r"brb2l7^r^-^ 

^^^^p^'IddlTi  or  s  1 

-references  relating 

to  reciprocity  with 


1^1 1 


This  book  is  DUE  on  the  last 
date  stamped  below 


if 


">ii-l 

^^^^ 


